What We Heard: Consultation on the review of the Ozone-depleting Substances and Halocarbon Alternatives Regulations
1. Introduction
The Ozone-depleting Substances and Halocarbon Alternatives Regulations(the Regulations) are made under Part 5 of the Canadian Environmental Protection Act. These regulations implement Canada’s international obligations under the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer (Montreal Protocol) to phase out ozone-depleting substances (ODS) and phase down hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs). While HFCs do not deplete the ozone layer, they are powerful greenhouse gases with global warming potentials (GWPs) that can be hundreds to thousands of times more potent than carbon dioxide.
The Regulations have been in place since 2016 and have not been substantively amended since 2017, when the HFC phasedown and product controls were established. The Regulations implement the phasedown by prohibiting the manufacture of HFCs and decreasing authorizations to import HFCs over time. This averts future releases to the environment and supports Canada's efforts to combat climate change. The Regulations also reduce demand for HFCs by restricting the import and manufacture of certain products containing HFCs including:
- aerosol products where HFCs are used as a propellant
- foam products where HFCs are used as foaming agents
- refrigeration or air conditioning equipment where HFCs are used as refrigerants
Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC) initiated a review of the Regulations in 2024 under ECCC’s Regulatory stock review plan. ECCC advanced this review due to interest from stakeholders, regulatory progress in other jurisdictions and in consideration of progress made towards the adoption of alternatives. The purpose of the review was to ensure that the Regulations continue to be effective and are achieving their intended policy objectives, and also to assess the impacts and burden of the Regulations on Canadians.
In support of the regulatory review process, ECCC consulted with external stakeholders and the general public. This report summarizes what we heard during the consultation period.
2. How we consulted
As part of the regulatory review, ECCC initiated pre-consultation in April 2024 to increase awareness of the process. ECCC contacted roughly 2,500 known stakeholders by e-mail to inform them of the decision to review the Regulations and of upcoming consultation opportunities.
On July 2, 2024, ECCC published a consultation document to seek input from interested parties. The consultation document (Appendix A) included a series of guiding questions and invited respondents to comment on the Regulations, with a view to improving their efficacy. ECCC solicited written input on the consultation document between July 2 and August 9, 2024.
3. Who participated
ECCC received over 90 written responses, representing the views of over 70 different parties, including:
- academia and laboratories (8%)
- members of the public (3%)
- non-governmental organizations (6%)
- other federal and provincial government departments (8%)
- industry respondents (75%)
Industry respondents included associations (~35%), importers and producers of HFCs (~20%), refrigeration and air conditioning (RAC) equipment (~25%), foam products (~10%) and aerosols (~10%).
4. What we heard
This section presents a summary of the comments received on the main themes, as outlined in the consultation document. It does not attribute any input to specific submissions.
For more information on the specific discussion questions included in the consultation document, please refer to Appendix I.
HFC phasedown
Most comments received show strong support for the phasedown on HFC consumption. A small number of industry responses recommended slowing the phasedown, due to a lack of available alternatives. A similar number recommended advancing the phasedown to further encourage industry to develop and transition to alternatives.
Most industry stakeholders would not support restricting transfers of HFC consumption allowances between end-uses (e.g. blowing agent and refrigerant). They noted this could reduce the availability of HFCs for critical needs in Canada. However, a few industry and non-government respondents would support such restrictions. These respondents noted this could prevent delays in the transition to alternatives. These respondents also supported permanently retiring allowances from applications that have transitioned and applying small offsets to transfers to discourage unneeded trading.
Industry respondents expressed different views on whether ECCC should include used recovered, recycled and reclaimed (URRR) HFCs under the phasedown and consumption allowance system. Some noted that including URRR under the phasedown could reduce the domestic supply of HFCs and capacity to service existing equipment. These respondents also emphasized that encouraging the use of URRR reduces global demand for new HFCs and drives responsible recovery and reclamation practices.
However, others noted that excluding URRR from the phasedown could prolong the use of high-GWP HFCs when other alternatives exist. These respondents also noted that excluding URRR is not consistent with the regulations now in place in the United States.
Some industry respondents recommended establishing guidelines for what qualifies as URRR and measures to verify imports, in order to support compliance with the HFC phasedown. Some also recommended establishing a requirement to use URRR for a proportion of domestic servicing needs. These respondents noted this proportion could increase over time, as best practices improve and the HFC phasedown progresses.
Several respondents highlighted that hydrofluoroolefins (HFOs) are important alternatives to HFCs. They noted that any uncertainty around risk management actions for per- and polyfluoroalkyl (PFAS), including HFOs, could delay research and development of low-GWP alternatives.
Controls on products containing ODS and HFCs
Aerosols
Almost all industry respondents support the GWP limit of 150 for pressurized containers and the exceptions listed in the Regulations. However, some non-government respondents recommended that the exception for healthcare products, including metered-dose inhalers, be phased-out once alternatives become available.
A few respondents noted some technical aerosols (e.g. refrigerant flushes) do not have alternatives to HFC-134a and are not excepted under the Regulations. These respondents recommended that, in these cases, ECCC provide exemptions aligned with regulations now in place in the United States. Some also noted that the Volatile Organic Compound Concentration Limits for Certain Products Regulations could limit the choice of propellants and delay the transition to alternatives.
Foams
Several submissions noted there are presently no alternatives to foaming agent blends that use low-GWP (<150) HFCs. As such, these respondents would not support more restrictive GWP limits or a complete phase-out of HFCs in foams. These respondents noted it can take upwards of 15 years to develop an alternative foaming agent and that energy efficiency remains a significant barrier to phasing out HFCs entirely.
Refrigeration and air conditioning systems
Many industry respondents noted that the transition to HFOs and other low GWP alternatives in refrigeration and air conditioning (RAC) systems is progressing well. Many noted that although solutions to replace HFCs exist, barriers such as building codes and safety standards can prevent the adoption of ultra-low GWP (<150) technology.
A few respondents noted that the Schedule 1.1 definitions for RAC systems lack in detail, which can lead to misunderstanding of the Regulations. In this regard, respondents most commonly identified the definition of a ‘chiller’ (item 5).
Many industry respondents noted differences exist for certain GWP limits, product definitions, and compliance deadlines between the Regulations and regulations now in place in the United States. These respondents suggested that increasing alignment with the United States could benefit Canadians, through lower costs, increased production efficiency and a more predictable marketplace.
Product controls in general
Most respondents supported the essential purpose permit provisions and ECCC’s recent efforts to increase transparency about permits that have been issued. However, some noted the decision-making process lacks public engagement and suggested that ECCC undertake stakeholder consultations when it assesses applications for essential purpose permits.
Several submissions noted that, at present, it is not possible to recycle HFOs or HFC/HFO refrigerant blends. These respondents also noted that using URRR HFCs in certain products would require extensive testing and certification (e.g. foams) and in some cases would not possible (e.g. metered-dose inhalers).
New and specialized uses of HFCs
Industry respondents identified a number of specialized uses for HFCs, for which there are no alternatives available. These uses will continue to rely on the domestic market for HFCs, whether as URRR from existing equipment or new HFCs imported under a consumption allowance:
- specialized laboratory equipment
- dielectric fluids
- heat pumps used for water heating
- microchip applications (e.g. plasma etching and vapor chamber cleaning)
- thermal management systems in electric vehicles
- very-low temperature (< -50C) industrial process refrigeration
Other issues
In general, respondents reported that the processes in place for permitting and annual reporting under the Regulations are effective. However, some submissions identified opportunities to reduce the related administrative burden on companies. For example, many respondents recommended ECCC establish an online portal to submit applications for permits and annual reports. These respondents also noted the importance of having technical support available, should ECCC adopt such a system.
Multiple industry respondents recommended ECCC change the annual reporting deadline from January 31 to February 28, to provide more time for report preparation following fiscal year-end. Some of these respondents also recommended that ECCC allow companies to report consumption by refrigerant blend, to simplify reporting obligations and reduce the potential for errors.
Several respondents recommended ECCC reduce or eliminate reporting obligations for imports of controlled substances for laboratory or analytical use. These respondents noted the regulatory burden is significant relative to the very small quantities imported.
Most stakeholders said they are satisfied with the information on the Regulations that they receive from ECCC. However, some added ECCC could improve public access to this information by publishing documents (e.g. factsheets and forms) and notifications of engagement opportunities through a centralized webpage.
Some stakeholders also recommended ECCC initiate public progress reporting on the Regulations. For example, some suggested that ECCC publish the quantities of HFCs imported each year and details on enforcement actions, in order to increase transparency and encourage compliance.
5. Outcome and next steps
ECCC considered all input received, as summarized in this document, during its review of the Regulations. The review is now complete and ECCC will publish the results and outcomes to the Regulatory stock review plan website.
The review found that the phasedown on HFC consumption and transition towards low-GWP alternatives is progressing well, despite some differences from similar controls established in other jurisdictions. Most importantly, the review concluded that Canada is meeting the requirements of the Montreal Protocol.
The review concluded there is no need to amend the Regulations at this time. ECCC will consider additional actions to address some of the issues identified during the review. ECCC plans to develop additional guidance and information to improve understanding of the Regulations. ECCC will determine any further regulatory action regarding the Regulations based on its regulatory agenda.
Appendix I: Questions from the Consultation Document: review of the Ozone-depleting Substances and Halocarbon Alternatives Regulations
The questions in this appendix are the same as those in the consultation document.
HFC phase-down
Would you foresee market supply challenges if the import of used, recovered, recycled or regenerated HFCs were included as part of the phase-down calculations?
What factors should be assessed when considering measures to restrict transfers of HFC allowances between sectors?
Controls on products containing HFCs and ODS
The current Regulations do not control all types of products that contain HFCs. The addition of controls on products containing HFCs including refrigeration, air conditioning and heating equipment, aerosols, foams and fire extinguishing equipment is being considered. Are you aware of product types that have no known alternatives to HFCs?
Longer term GWP targets for product controls may be considered to support long term HFC phase-down objectives. What technical barriers would prevent adoption of very low GWP alternatives to HFCs in the refrigeration and air conditioning sectors and how much time would be needed to transition to very low GWP alternatives?
The Regulations control products across sectors and include definitions for many product types. Given the common use of HFCs in a number of applications in the refrigeration and air conditioning, foams, aerosol and other sectors, how could product definitions be improved and/or standardized to ensure clarity regarding to which products specific controls apply?
Are exceptions for specialized aerosol products that are currently listed under subsections 64.6(2) and (3) still necessary? If so, which ones in particular?
New and specialized uses of HFCs
Do you have information on new or specialized uses of HFCs, in Canada or elsewhere, that fall outside the known uses identified above?
Administrative burden and other issues
What could facilitate the permit, allowance transfer or annual reporting processes?
Have you experienced unexpected or unintended administrative barriers or burden as a regulated entity under the Regulations?