What happens if you break the rules when giving advice or representation

We have a penalty system to make sure people who give advice or representation follow the law. If you get paid for giving advice or representation and we find that you broke the law, you will have to pay a monetary penalty and a summary of your violations will be published.

You are breaking the law if you receive payment or other compensation and:

Our goal is to encourage you to follow the law, not punish misbehaviour. This system works alongside other functions of professional discipline by governing bodies and criminal enforcement by the Canada Border Services Agency and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, which may conduct their own investigation and prosecution of criminal offences such as fraud, misrepresentation and counselling misrepresentation.

If we find that you’ve broken the law, we will:

  1. issue you a monetary penalty
  2. publish your name and the information relevant to your misconduct on our website

Who this applies to

These rules apply to anyone who gives advice or representation for payment, no matter where you are located. If you’re outside Canada and are found to have broken the rules, we’ll still issue penalties and publish your name and details about the misconduct on our website.

These regulations are meant to motivate you to comply with the law, not to punish misconduct. If you get a notice of violation, you won’t be penalized in the future for any misconduct that happened before the date on that notice. These regulations will also only apply to misconduct that happens after they have come into force.

The monetary penalty will increase depending on how seriously and how often you violate the rules.

How the process works

  1. Inspection

    If an officer has reasonable grounds to suspect you have broken the rules, they can begin an inspection of documents to verify that you have complied.

    We may require you to provide relevant documents by a specified deadline.

    If you don’t comply with a requirement for documents, the financial penalty is $10,000. This amount will be added to penalties for any other violations you have been found liable for. The amount may increase or decrease depending on any prior violations.

    If you are not able to provide documents

    You may not be able to provide relevant documents due to:

    • litigation privilege
    • solicitor-client privilege
    • professional secrecy of advocates and notaries

    This may affect you if you are:

    • a lawyer who is a member in good standing of a law society of a province or territory
    • a notary who is a member in good standing of the Chambre des notaires du Quebec
    • a student-at-law acting under the supervision of a lawyer or notary in good standing

    If privileged documents prevent you from adequately defending yourself against allegations of misconduct, you can submit an affidavit saying so within the specified deadline.

  2. Receive a preliminary notice

    If an officer has reasonable grounds to believe that you’ve broken the rules, we may send you a preliminary notice.

    If you receive a preliminary notice, you have 30 days from the date you get it to:

    • make a written submission in response to the alleged violation(s), facts and monetary penalty
    • submit an affidavit attesting that you can’t contest the alleged facts without disclosing information that is subject to:
      • litigation privilege
      • solicitor-client privilege
      • professional secrecy of advocates and notaries
    • request an extension of the 30-day period

    We will review any submissions relating to the alleged violations.

    If you can’t provide documents: see no. 1 above for more information.

    What your preliminary notice includes

    A preliminary notice includes:

    • your name
    • the violation(s) and alleged facts
    • information on the consequences: a monetary penalty and publishing your information online
    • the details and total monetary penalty
    • information on how to respond to IRCC on the alleged facts and penalty
  3. Receive a notice of violation

    After we review any responses to the preliminary notice, if it is determined on a balance of probabilities that you broke the rules, we may send you a notice of violation.

    If you receive a notice of violation, you have 30 days from the date you get it to:

    • pay the monetary penalty
    • request a review from a Governor in Council–appointed reviewer

    What your notice of violation includes

    A notice of violation will include:

    • your name
    • the violation(s) and relevant facts
    • information on the consequences: a monetary penalty and publishing your information online
    • the details and total monetary penalty
    • information on how to request a review
    • information on how to pay the monetary penalty
  4. Pay a monetary penalty

    The amount of a monetary penalty depends on what rule you break, and how many times you break it. The penalty could range from a few thousand dollars to tens of thousands of dollars per incident.

    If you break the rules multiple times, the penalties could add up to a maximum of $1.5 million per notice. If the violation resulted in financial profit, that profit will also be added to the penalty.

    Whether or not you have paid the penalties will be shown on our website.

    Within 30 days of receiving the notice of violation you must:

    • pay the monetary penalty in full, or
    • enter into a payment agreement with the Minister

    You can do so by calling IRCC Finance: 1-888-448-4426.

    Please direct all questions regarding payment to: IRCC.FINDTTC-DALCFIN.IRCC@cic.gc.ca.

    How monetary penalties are calculated

    The monetary penalty is calculated using this formula: (A + B + C) x D

    • baseline amount – based on the specific rule you broke
    • impact – if it led to an error in administration of the acts
    • financial advantage – if you received one from committing the violation
    • multiplier – a multiplier based on how many times you have been found guilty of violations in the past
    How monetary penalties are calculated
    A B C D
    Baseline penalty Impact of violation Financial advantage Multiplier
    Set amount based on the provision you violated If applicable, if an error in the administration of the act occurred from the violation If applicable, amount you received in connection with the violation Based on your previously committed violations
    Provision violated Amount Provision violated Amount Past findings Amount
    IRPR 315.47 $5,000 IRPR 315.47 $0 0 0.5
    IRPR 315.48(a) $15,000 IRPR 315.48(a) $15,000
    IRPR 315.48(b) $15,000 IRPR 315.48(b) $15,000
    IRPR 315.48(c) $15,000 IRPR 315.48(c) $15,000 1 1.0
    Citizenship Regulations 36 $5,000 Citizenship Regulations 36 $0
    Citizenship Regulations 37(a) $15,000 Citizenship Regulations 37(a) $15,000
    Citizenship Regulations 37(b) $15,000 Citizenship Regulations 37(b) $15,000 2 or more 1.5
    Citizenship Regulations 37(c) $15,000 Citizenship Regulations 37(c) $15,000
    IRPR 315.49(3) $10,000    
    Citizenship Regulations 38(3) $10,000

    Source: Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations and the Citizenship Regulations

    If you don’t comply with a requirement for documents, the base penalty amount is $10,000. This amount may increase if you have received penalties in the past.

  5. Request a review (optional)

    Within 30 days of receiving the notice of violation, you can ask for a review of the notice or of the penalties, or both.

    The reviewer will decide if on a balance of probabilities whether you committed the violation(s), and if so, whether the penalty amount was issued correctly.

    The reviewer can decide if the violation:

    • did not happen
    • happened and the monetary penalty is correct
    • happened and the monetary penalty should be higher or lower

    The reviewer will send you a notice of decision.

    What your notice of decision includes

    Your notice of decision will include:

    • your name
    • the violation(s) and relevant facts
    • the decision and reasons for it
    • whether you need to pay a monetary penalty and have your information published online
    • the details and total monetary penalty
    • information on the right to apply for judicial review
    • information on how to pay the monetary penalty
  6. We publish your information online

    If we find you broke the rules, we’ll publish your information on our list of non-compliant people who provide representation or advice. Our website will publish:

    • your name and the name of your business or employer
    • the date when the notice of violation was issued to you, or the date of the notice of decision if you requested a review
    • the type of violation(s)
    • the amount of the monetary penalty
    • whether you’ve paid the monetary penalty

More information

Find out more about the regulations for immigration and citizenship.

Page details

2026-10-28