Chapter 1: Human Antimicrobial Drug Use Report 2012/2013 – Physician diagnosis data

1. Physician Diagnosis Data

The Canadian Disease and Therapeutic index (CDTI) dataset provides information about the patterns and treatments of disease encountered by office-based physicians (specialists and general practitioners, including those with offices in hospitals). These data are presented over three geographic regions in Canada: West (British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba); Central (Québec and Ontario), and East (New Brunswick, Newfoundland and Labrador, Nova Scotia, and Prince Edward Island).

The sample of physicians represents all major specialties across Canada. Data from 652 physicians were available in 2013 and projection methods used to extrapolate data to the universe of approximately 55,092 physicians in Canada.

The information contained in this analysis is for drugs for which a physician has provided a recommendation or prescription, and does not represent actual prescriptions dispensed by pharmacists or consumed by the patient. These data do not include patient visits to a primary care nurse. Furthermore, diagnosis visits do not translate into the total number of patients, as some patients visited multiple times for the same reason, or were diagnosed with multiple diseases. Due to the methods of data collection, the sample size may be considered too small for decision making. However, this information is included in this analysis to provide a view of antimicrobial recommendation practices which may require further studies.

More detailed information on IMS Health Canada data collection and PHAC's analytic methods are described in Appendix A.

National Diagnosis Data

In 2013, Canadian physicians saw patients for >293 million diagnoses, and provided more than 23.8 million antimicrobial recommendations for these diagnoses (Table 1.1). This reflects approximately 82,800 diagnoses per 10,000 Canadian inhabitants, with 8% of all diagnoses resulting with an antimicrobial recommendation.

Antimicrobial recommendations by diagnostic class

In 2013, the diagnostic classes with the greatest number of antimicrobial recommendations / 10,000 inhabitants were upper respiratory tract infections (1,061 recommendations / 10, 000 inhabitants), lower UTI or cystitis (924 recommendations / 10,000 inhabitants), and diseases of the ear (703 recommendations / 10,000 inhabitants). Although these three diagnostic classes had the greatest number of recommendations, they differ from the diagnostic classes with the highest proportion of recommendations per diagnoses. Pneumonia and acute sinusitis had antimicrobial recommendations for 84.5% and 83.5% of diagnoses, respectively. Acute bronchitis had a recommendation rate of 77.9% (Table 1.1). Similarly, these were also the diagnostic classes with the highest rate of antimicrobial recommendation in 2012 (Table 1.2 and Appendix Table B.1).

Over the 2007 – 2013 time frame, the diagnostic classes with the greatest change in recommendation rates were the upper UTI or pyelonephritis (12.5% reduction), pneumonia(9.4% increase), chronic sinusitis (6.3% reduction), and acne (6.0% reduction) (Table 1.2) (Figure 1.1).

The particular antimicrobial drug recommended varied by the class of diagnosis made (Table 1.3). These data display that for particular diagnostic classes (e.g., diseases of the ear, upper respiratory tract infections) a single antimicrobial was recommended at a much higher rate than others. Conversely, diagnostic classes such as chronic sinusitis and acute bronchitis have no single "preferred" drug. No major changes were observed in the recommendation rates for the specific diagnosis-drug combinations with the exception of the use of levofloxacin for treating pneumonia. The recommendation rate of levofloxacin dropped from 25 recommendations / 10,000 inhabitants in 2011 to 9 recommendations / 10,000 inhabitants in 2012. In 2013, the rate was 28 recommendations / 10,000 inhabitants.

Table 1.1: Total number of office-based diagnoses, diagnosis rate, total number of antimicrobial recommendations, antimicrobial recommendation rate, and percentage of diagnoses with antimicrobial recommendations by office-based physicians in Canada, by diagnostic class, 20131.
Diagnostic Class Total diagnoses Number of diagnoses
/ 10,000 inhabitants
Antimicrobial recommendations (N) Number of antimicrobial recommendations
/ 10,000 individuals
Percentage of diagnoses with antimicrobial recommendations
Acne 2211530 623.97 452240 127.60 20.45
Acute bronchitis 2844550 802.57 2214510 624.81 77.85
Acute sinusitis 1644900 464.10 1373790 387.61 83.52
Chronic bronchitis 1114640 314.49 747200 210.82 67.04
Chronic sinusitis 1176910 332.06 608910 171.80 51.74
Disease of the gastrointestinal system 20372310 5747.93 1178850 327.74 5.79
Diseases of the ear 9686880 2733.10 2497020 702.96 25.78
Injuries and poisonings 13350560 3766.78 438040 123.59 3.28
Lower UTI or Cystitis 4755520 1341.74 3275220 924.08 68.87
Other diseases of the genitourinary system 14781490 4170.51 1467820 414.14 9.93
Other respiratory tract infections 16030240 4522.84 1190590 335.92 7.43
Other skin and soft tissue infections 16391170 4624.67 940590 212.56 5.74
Pneumonia 1258540 355.09 1062970 299.91 84.46
SSTIs 2815660 794.42 1816860 512.62 64.53
Symptoms and ill-defined conditions 21703010 6123.38 346580 92.58 1.60
Upper respiratory tract infections 11538380 3255.49 3760560 1061.02 32.59
TOTAL 293468260 82800.35 23778840 6709.06 8.10

1Data does not represent actual prescriptions dispensed by pharmacists or products consumed by the patient, as information on patient compliance was not available. Diagnosis does not represent the number of times a person visits, but represents every time a diagnosis is provided; if a person presents with multiple diseases each individual disease/diagnosis is recorded separately.

Diagnostic classes were removed from this table if they represented < 1% of antimicrobial mentions in 2013. These classes were: complications of pregnancy, childbirth, and puerperium; congenital anomalities; diseases of the central nervous system; diseases of the circulatory system; diseases of the sense organs; endocrine, nutritional, metabolic, and immunity diseases; musculoskeletal diseases; neoplasms; perinatal conditions; supplementary classifications; and upper UTI or pyelonephritis.

Table 1.2 : Percent of diagnoses receiving antimicrobial recommendations provided by office-based physicians in Canada by diagnostic class, by year, 2007–2013 1
Diagnostic Class 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 RankTable 1.2 - Footnote *
Acne 26.5 21.0 21.7 25.2 18.3 25.0 20.4 11
Acute bronchitis 78.9 77.3 80.9 85.1 82.1 77.0 77.9 4
Acute sinusitis 86.7 87.6 83.7 81.6 86.7 87.8 83.5 3
Chronic bronchitis 68.7 70.1 68.6 59.5 74.5 71.3 67.0 6
Chronic sinusitis 58.0 58.2 56.7 51.9 48.8 51.3 51.7 8
Complications of pregnancy, childbirth, and puerperal 1.0 2.1 4.5 4.1 4.9 4.1 5.1 16
Disease of the gastrointestinal system 4.6 4.8 5.1 5.3 5.0 5.9 5.7 15
Diseases of the ear 26.8 29.2 27.6 25.5 25.2 26.8 25.7 10
Lower UTI or Cystitis 73.5 73.3 76.0 69.3 68.3 67.3 68.9 5
Other diseases of the genitourinary system 6.4 6.9 6.6 10.3 9.8 9.7 9.9 12
Other respiratory tract infections 8.4 8.5 7.2 8.6 7.1 6.6 7.4 13
Other skin and soft tissue infections 2.7 3.1 2.9 4.4 3.7 4.1 4.6 17
Perinatal conditions 2.4 6.3 4.0 7.4 3.9 2.4 5.8 14
Pneumonia 75.0 80.9 77.3 84.8 76.6 82.1 84.5 2
SSTIs 58.6 59.9 64.9 62.1 60.6 65.2 64.5 7
Upper respiratory tract infections 35.1 32.1 31.2 31.5 33.3 32.8 32.6 9
Upper UTI or Pyelonephritis 97.0 74.0 Table 1.2 - Footnote * 97.6 81.1 77.4 84.5 1
Footnote 1
1Data does not represent actual prescriptions dispensed by pharmacists or products consumed by the patient, as information on patient compliance was not available. Diagnosis does not represent the number of times a person visits, but represents every time a diagnosis is provided; if a person presents with multiple diseases each individual disease/diagnosis is recorded separately.
Footnote *
*Data for Upper UTI or Pyelonephritis in 2009 were removed due to obvious data recording errors Diagnostic classes were removed from this table if < 5% of visits resulted in an antimicrobial recommendation. These classes were: congenital anomalies; diseases of the central nervous system; diseases of the circulatory system; diseases of the sense organs; endocrine, nutritional, metabolic, and immunity diseases; injuries and poisonings; mental disorders; musculoskeletal diseases; neoplasms; supplementary classifications; and symptoms and ill-defined conditions. Ranked from highest rate of recommendation to lowest rate in 2013.

Figure 1.1. Percent of diagnoses that received an antimicrobial recommendation by office-based physicians in Canada, 2007, 2009, 2011 and 20131.

Figure 1.1
Text equivalent for figure 1Percent of diagnoses that received an antimicrobial recommendation by office-based physicians in Canada, 2007, 2009, 2011 and 2013
  Proportion of diagnoses receiving an antimicrobial recommendation
Disease Classification 2007 2009 2011 2013
Upper UTI 97.0%   81.1% 84.5%
Upper RTIs 35.2% 31.2% 33.3% 32.6%
SSTIs 58.6% 64.9% 60.6% 64.5%
Pneumonia 75.0% 77.3% 76.6% 84.5%
Lower UTIs 73.5% 76.0% 68.3% 68.9%
Diseases of the ear 26.8% 27.6% 25.2% 25.7%
Chronic sinusitis 58.0% 56.7% 48.8% 51.7%
Chronic bronchitis 68.7% 68.6% 74.5% 67.0%
Acute sinusitis 86.7% 83.7% 86.7% 83.5%
Acute bronchitis 78.9% 80.9% 82.1% 77.9%
Acne 26.5% 21.7% 18.3% 20.4%
Table 1.3 : Number of antimicrobial recommendations by office-based physicians in Canada, by diagnostic class, antimicrobial and year (2007 – 2013) 1
Diagnostic Class Antimicrobial recommended Number of antimicrobial recommendations
/ 10,000 inhabitants
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Acute bronchitis Amoxicillin 262 249 266 267 277 194 211
Amoxicillin and enzyme inhibitor 124 124 96 121 139 155 160
Ampicillin 114 132 102 92 94 87 134
Azithromycin 69 85 65 72 69 60 52
Cefaclor 18 17 19 16 17 8 15
Other antimicrobials 102 71 79 68 58 57 53
TOTAL 688 679 628 637 653 560 625
Acute sinusitis Amoxicillin 104 110 110 106 124 120 154
Clarithromycin 147 175 159 155 137 111 76
Amoxicillin and enzyme inhibitor 30 34 35 24 42 25 35
Moxifloxacin 54 45 47 50 49 54 32
Azithromycin 48 50 38 25 34 40 29
Other antimicrobials 133 102 122 90 90 59 61
TOTAL 517 516 511 450 477 407 388
Chronic bronchitis Clarithromycin 81 83 85 63 70 55 68
Azithromycin 84 90 60 65 45 56 42
Amoxicillin 66 64 44 33 31 58 42
Moxifloxacin 37 39 30 29 42 33 25
Amoxicillin and enzyme inhibitor 5 8 6 6 7 8 13
Other antimicrobials 36 52 55 16 42 30 21
TOTAL 309 336 279 212 237 239 211
Chronic sinusitis Amoxicillin 51 46 75 51 56 62 44
Clarithromycin 63 69 72 56 61 44 42
Azithromycin 46 32 16 19 14 20 22
Moxifloxacin 30 36 26 10 26 13 19
Amoxicillin and enzyme inhibitor 31 29 39 19 15 24 19
Other antimicrobials 45 33 53 38 21 29 26
TOTAL 266 245 279 192 194 193 172
Diseases of the ear Amoxicillin 303 390 380 373 362 386 431
Cefprozil 76 81 60 56 66 71 66
Clarithromycin 112 122 108 112 110 100 61
Azithromycin 45 70 70 58 48 59 54
Amoxicillin and enzyme inhibitor 51 41 33 39 31 44 35
Other antimicrobials 97 84 84 48 44 31 56
TOTAL 685 789 736 685 661 692 703
Lower UTI or Cystitis Ciprofloxacin 467 460 471 454 437 465 426
Nitrofurantoin 276 280 287 317 294 321 339
Amoxicillin 34 38 36 27 33 33 42
Norfloxacin 67 52 76 36 25 20 41
Cephalexin 17 11 14 10 19 10 16
Other antimicrobials 228 210 185 100 66 56 61
TOTAL 1088 1051 1070 943 874 906 924
Pneumoniac Clarithromycin 113 96 97 115 102 106 93
Azithromycin 31 59 19 34 31 38 52
Moxifloxacin 72 72 77 86 87 90 47
Levofloxacin 25 37 25 13 25 9 28
Amoxicillin 11 15 23 28 35 34 23
Other antimicrobials 62 82 76 72 51 62 56
TOTAL 314 361 317 349 331 338 300
Skin and soft tissue infections Cephalexin 202 200 205 172 230 200 197
Cloxacillin 73 91 69 79 59 64 59
Amoxicillin 26 33 33 50 35 44 50
Cefadroxil 13 31 33 15 18 36 49
Clindamycin 26 19 39 46 26 23 38
Other antimicrobials 168 151 178 158 142 141 121
TOTAL 508 525 557 519 510 508 513
Upper UTI or Pyelonephritis Ciprofloxacin 11 12 18 8 11 15 15
Ceftriaxone 3 3 NR 5 6 4 2
Amoxicillin NR NR 3 NR NR 1 2
Nitrofurantoin NR NR NR <1 NR NR 2
Ertapenem NR NR NR NR NR NR 1
Other antimicrobials 9 2 9 10 3 6 NR
TOTAL 23 18 30 23 20 26 20
Upper respiratory tract infections Amoxicillin 596 523 567 520 560 494 537
Clarithromycin 198 157 175 156 132 119 167
Azithromycin 144 153 129 114 145 151 120
Penicillin V 181 168 141 145 127 130 118
Amoxicillin and enzyme inhibitor 15 29 32 19 28 25 36
Other antimicrobials 188 154 137 111 137 127 83
TOTAL 1322 1186 1181 1066 1129 1046 1061
Footnote 1
1Data does not represent actual prescriptions dispensed by pharmacists or products consumed by the patient, as information on patient compliance was not available. Diagnosis does not represent the number of times a person visits, but represents every time a diagnosis is provided; if a person presents with multiple diseases each individual disease/diagnosis is recorded separately.

Recommendations by age group and gender

The rate of antimicrobial recommendation varied in 2013 by the age and sex of the patient (Table 1.4). Although the number of diagnoses per 10,000 inhabitants was highest in the 65+ age group, this group was the least likely to receive an antimicrobial recommendation. Children aged 0-2 had the highest raw number of recommendations / 10,000 inhabitants, but children aged 3-9 had the highest percentage of diagnoses resulting in an antimicrobial recommendation.

Generally, children had a higher rate of antimicrobial recommendation than adults in 2013, and female patients were more likely to receive an antimicrobial recommendation than male patients (Table 1.4).

The class of antimicrobial recommended also varied in 2013 by the age of the patient (Figure 1.2). Children (i.e., age groups 0-2, 3-9) were more likely to receive a recommendation for penicillins or second generation cephalosporins than adults, while adults were more likely to receive quinolone or tetracycline recommendations than children. Recommendations for first generation cephalosporins were relatively similar among the age groups.

Table 1.4 : Diagnosis rate, antimicrobial recommendation rate and percentage of diagnosis with antimicrobial recommendation provided by office-based physicians in Canada, by age and by gender, 2013 1
Demographic (age or sex) Number of diagnoses / 10,000 inhabitants Number of antimicrobial recommendations / 10,000 individuals Percentage of diagnoses with antimicrobial recommendations
Age group
0-2 113737.24 12344.61 10.13
3-9 56165.78 8644.25 15.39
10-19 49524.59 5569.25 11.20
20-39 66977.50 6413.98 9.57
40-59 92182.72 6091.54 6.59
60-64 134358.17 6640.77 4.94
65+ 155558.50 7206.63 4.52
Unspecified N/A N/A 5.25
Sex
Female 103374.19 8012.90 7.75
Male 80064.97 5348.99 6.68
Unspecified N/A N/A 6.40
Footnote 1
1Data does not represent actual prescriptions dispensed by pharmacists or products consumed by the patient, as information on patient compliance was not available. Diagnosis does not represent the number of times a person visits, but represents every time a diagnosis is provided; if a person presents with multiple diseases each individual disease/diagnosis is recorded separately.

Figure 1.2. Total number of antimicrobial recommendations / 10,000 inhabitants provided by office-based physicians in Canada, by age and antimicrobial classification, 2013Footnote 1 Footnote 2.

Figure 1.2
Text equivalent for figure 1.2Total number of antimicrobial recommendations / 10,000 inhabitants provided by office-based physicians in Canada, by age and antimicrobial classification, 2013
Antimicrobial Therapeutic Classification Number of antimicrobial recommendations per 10,000 inhabitants, by age group
0-2 3-9 10-19 20-39 40-59 60-64 65+
J01DB First-generation cephalosporins 352 357 492 534 498 602 567
J01F Macrolides, lincosamides and streptogramins 2427 1671 1019 1540 1625 2046 1551
J01X Other antimicrobials 110 59 534 825 740 550 999
J01CA & J01CR Penicillins with extended spectrum 6749 5562 2049 1461 1391 1141 1156
J01MA Quinolone antibacterials 0 52 198 1027 1080 1643 1954
J01DC Second-generation cephalosporins 1204 716 204 130 134 86 252
J01AA Tetracyclines 0 0 418 377 231 240 220
J01DD Third-generation cephalosporins 366 136 90 98 112 108 171

Recommendations by region

In 2013, the diagnosis rate, antimicrobial recommendation rate and percentage of diagnoses with antimicrobial recommendations varied by region in Canada (Table 1.5). The Eastern region had a higher number of diagnostic classes for which a higher rate of diagnosis and antimicrobial recommendations were provided. However, the Central region had more diagnostic classes with higher percentage of diagnoses with antimicrobial recommendations compared to the other two Canadian regions.

The “preferred” antimicrobial drug recommended for treating the different diagnoses seemed consistent across the regions, with the exception of three diagnoses: acute bronchitis, chronic bronchitis and chronic sinusitis (Table 1.6). Although the West and Central regions primarily recommended the same drug for the treatment of both acute bronchitis (clarithromycin) and chronic sinusitis (amoxicillin), the East region recommended a different drug for these two diagnoses (azithromycin and clarithromycin, respectively). These data display that for particular diagnostic classes (e.g. chronic sinusitis, upper respiratory tract infections, pneumonia and SSTIs) a single antimicrobial is recommended at a much higher rate than others.

Table 1.5 : Diagnosis rate, antimicrobial recommendation rate and percentage of diagnoses with antimicrobial recommendations provided by office-based physicians in Canada, by diagnostic class and region, 2013 1
Diagnostic Class Region Number of antimicrobial recommendations / 10,000 individuals Number of diagnoses / 10,000 inhabitants Percentage of diagnoses with antimicrobial recommendations
Acne Central 141 670 21
East 148 771 19
West 97 500 19
Acute bronchitis Central 691 916 75
East 271 355 76
West 570 675 84
Acute sinusitis Central 444 503 88
East 472 557 85
West 258 366 71
Chronic bronchitis Central 198 288 69
East 323 559 58
West 212 314 68
Chronic sinusitis Central 157 282 56
East 311 583 53
West 170 377 45
Disease of the gastrointestinal system Central 326 5389 6
East 437 8929 5
West 307 5768 5
Diseases of the ear Central 810 2761 29
East 578 4741 12
West 519 2243 23
Injuries and poisonings Central 113 3364 3
East 117 2368 5
West 147 4866 3
Lower UTI or Cystitis Central 908 1262 72
East 885 1459 61
West 964 1475 65
Other diseases of the genitourinary system Central 402 4097 10
East 490 4601 11
West 422 4223 10
Other respiratory tract infections Central 284 4579 6
East 624 5099 12
West 375 4287 9
Other skin and soft tissue infections Central 185 4460 4
East 460 5118 9
West 213 4844 4
Pneumonia Central 355 395 90
East 306 436 70
West 191 259 74
SSTIs Central 445 717 62
East 460 687 67
West 658 970 68
Upper respiratory tract infections Central 999 3337 30
East 1615 3576 45
West 1064 3025 35
Footnote 1
1Data does not represent actual prescriptions dispensed by pharmacists or products consumed by the patient, as information on patient compliance was not available. Diagnosis does not represent the number of times a person visits, but represents every time a diagnosis is provided; if a person presents with multiple diseases each individual disease/diagnosis is recorded separately.
Table 1.6 : Antimicrobial recommendation rate provided by office-based physicians in Canada, by diagnostic class, antimicrobial and region, 2013 1
Diagnostic Class Antimicrobial Recommended Number of antimicrobial recommendations / 10,000 inhabitants
West Central East
Acute bronchitis Amoxicillin 107 155 59
Clarithromycin 198 238 24
Azithromycin 186 152 116
Moxifloxacin 24 69 24
Cefixime 5 3 48
Other antimicrobials 49 75 0
Total 570 691 271
Acute sinusitis Amoxicillin 114 178 117
Clarithromycin 42 97 47
Amoxicillin and enzyme inhibitor 5 43 95
Cefuroxime 5 26 94
Azithromycin 31 26 48
Other antimicrobials 62 74 70
Total 258 444 472
Chronic bronchitis Amoxicillin 36 48 12
Clarithromycin 104 36 189
Azithromycin 10 55 70
Moxifloxacin 15 32 NR
Cefuroxime 10 3 23
Other antimicrobials 36 23 29
Total 212 198 323
Chronic sinusitis Clarithromycin 49 27 143
Amoxicillin 51 41 36
Amoxicillin and enzyme inhibitor 26 10 62
Azithromycin 31 17 23
Cefuroxime 5 14 24
Other antimicrobials 8 47 23
Total 170 157 311
Diseases of the ear Amoxicillin 341 491 294
Cefprozil 8 90 119
Clarithromycin 57 67 23
Azithromycin 34 65 47
Amoxicillin and enzyme inhibitor 28 38 36
Other antimicrobials 50 58 59
Total 519 810 578
Lower UTI or Cystitis Amoxicillin 26 52 24
Ciprofloxacin 446 409 483
Nitrofurantoin 340 340 319
Norfloxacin 23 51 36
Cephalexin 31 11 NR
Other antimicrobials 99 46 23
Total 964 908 885
Pneumonia Clarithromycin 72 96 166
Azithromycin 21 68 47
Moxifloxacin 26 61 23
Levofloxacin 22 32 23
Amoxicillin 23 26 NR
Other antimicrobials 27 72 46
Total 191 355 306
SSTIs Cephalexin 349 117 223
Amoxicillin 59 43 67
Clindamycin 77 17 47
Cloxacillin 48 69 12
Clarithromycin 28 24 43
Other antimicrobials 97 174 69
Total 658 445 460
Upper UTI or Pyelonephritis Ciprofloxacin 16 16 NR
Ceftriaxone 5 NR NR
Nitrofurantoin 5 NR NR
Amoxicillin NR 3 NR
Ertapenem NR 1 NR
Total 26 20 0
Upper respiratory tract infections Amoxicillin 554 481 961
Azithromycin 72 131 238
Clarithromycin 238 133 153
Penicillin V 43 161 72
Amoxicillin and enzyme inhibitor 47 29 48
Other antimicrobials 109 63 142
Total 1064 999 1615

1 Data does not represent actual prescriptions dispensed by pharmacists or products consumed by the patient, as information on patient compliance was not available. Diagnosis does not represent the number of times a person visits, but represents every time a diagnosis is provided; if a person presents with multiple diseases each individual disease/diagnosis is recorded separately.

Page details

Date modified: