Evaluation of CSC’s Health Services, 2017
Evaluation Report
File #394-2-96
Evaluation of CSC’s Health Services
Evaluation Division
Policy Sector
March 2017
Signatures
Evaluation of CSC's Health Services
Don Head
Commissioner
Date: March 2017
Brigitte de Blois
Director, Evaluation Division
Date: March 2017
Contributions
Authors:
Kendra Delveaux, Senior Evaluation Manager
Colleen MacDonald, A/Senior Evaluator
Ashley McConnell, A/Evaluation Officer
Sheena Bradley, Evaluation Officer
Adam Crawford, Evaluation Analyst
Felicia Tse, Junior Evaluation Analyst
Evaluation Team Members:
Duyen Luong, Senior Evaluator
Hassimiou Ly, Senior Evaluator
Lysiane Marseille-Paquin, Evaluation Officer
Marcie McLean-McKay, Evaluation Officer
Tara Beauchamp, Evaluation Officer
Bertha May, Evaluation Officer
Donna Towns, Evaluation Officer
Elizabeth Loree, Junior Evaluation Analyst
Hortense Kambou, Junior Evaluation Analyst
Joel Ndayubaha, Junior Evaluation Analyst
Kossi Aziaba, Junior Evaluation Analyst
Kristen White, Junior Evaluation Analyst
Alex Lefebvre, Junior Evaluation Analyst
Acknowledgments
The evaluation team is grateful for the assistance provided by the Health Services Sector for their continued support with various aspects of this project. The evaluation team would like to express sincere appreciation to Marie-France Lapierre, Audrey Castonguay and Ginette Clarke for their ongoing efforts throughout the evaluation project. The evaluation team also wishes to extend their appreciation to the Women Offender Sector, Correctional Operations and Programs, and Aboriginal Initiatives Directorate, for their contributions in the pre-evaluation stages of the evaluation. The evaluation team would like to thank all members of the consultative group including Pat Barker (Drumheller Institution), Jennifer Gravelle (Health Services, Region), Peter Desjarlais (Aboriginal Initiatives Directorate), Marnie MacDonald (Women Offender Sector), Peter Glen (Correctional Operations and Programs), Luc Gregoire (Correctional Operations and Programs), Kent Merlin (Performance Management), James Matthew (Regional Operational Prairies Institution), Peter Wickwire (Regional Operational Atlantic Community), and Lynn Stewart (Research Branch) for their collaboration and contributions throughout the evaluation.
The evaluation team would like to express its appreciation to all those who participated in the collection of data at various CSC institutions and contributed valuable information, including Regional Directors, Wardens, District Directors, institutional and community staff members, and staff at NHQ. The evaluation team would like to extend their gratitude to all offenders who contributed to the evaluation by participating in interviews and sharing their overall experiences regarding health services throughout the continuum of care.
We would also like to thank the many branches and sectors of CSC who helped provide data for this evaluation, including the staff in Financial Management Services in the Comptroller's Branch who provided financial data and staff from Strategies, Planning, Measurement and Reporting who provided human resource data.
Finally, the evaluation team would like to thank everyone else who contributed to this evaluation, whose names do not appear here.
Executive Summary
According to section 86(1) of the Corrections and Conditional Release Act (CCRA), CSC is mandated to provide essential health care, and reasonable access to non-essential mental health care that will contribute to the inmate's rehabilitation and successful reintegration into the community.Endnote i
Compared to the Canadian population, offenders demonstrate a higher prevalence of mental and physical health concerns. As well, CSC's offender population is aging. In 2014-15, 24% of federal offenders were 50 years or older and the number of offenders over the age of 50 at admission has risen over the last ten years.Endnote ii In 2014-2015, Health Services accounted for approximately 11% of CSC's total direct program spending. CSC's Health Services represent an important opportunity to address offenders' diverse health care needs throughout the continuum of care, which includes: intake, incarceration, and pre-release and community supervision.
The evaluation focuses on the relevance and performance of CSC's mental, clinical, and public health services. Evaluation questions examine the following areas: relevancy of CSC's health services, effectiveness and efficiency of the intake assessment process, offender access to care and services throughout incarceration, public health education and harm reduction, institutional mental health services, pre-release and community health services and the management and coordination of health services. Given the breadth and complexity of health services within CSC, the evaluation is organized into seven findings in focus for evaluation (FIFEs).
Evaluation Results:
Overall, the evaluation found that CSC's Health Services are relevant and meet the needs of federal offenders. Positive impacts were found regarding institutional mental health care where offenders' had a reduced likelihood of incidents, serious charges and involuntary segregation following treatment. Several key areas were identified for service improvements and recommendations were made to support decision makers with improving the efficiency and effectiveness of CSC's Health Services. Program managers responded to these recommendations. The major recommendations and their associated management responses are outlined below.
- Maintain productive relationships with partners who support individuals with mental health disorders. CSC is responsible for providing health services to federal offenders; there is an ongoing need for partnerships to effectively and efficiently deliver these services to offenders.
- In response: CSC will strengthen partnerships to support the delivery of mental health services for federal offenders and will share information and practices related to mental health through the Federal Provincial Territorial Working Group on Health/Mental Health.
- Ensure offenders are referred to the appropriate mental health services. CSC has developed a Mental Health Need Scale to assess offenders' mental health need and determine the appropriate level of care required in accordance with its new refined model of mental health care (primary, intermediate, psychiatric hospital). The validity and reliability of this scale are yet to be assessed.
- In response: CSC will assess the validity and reliability of the Mental Health Needs Scale and will strengthen the process for recording and maintaining offender level of need data.
- Adopt measures to support a continuum of health care for offenders during their transition from CSC Health Services to provincial/territorial health coverage. Specifically, obtaining health cards and payment for community health services. Procedures in obtaining provincial/territorial health cards vary across regions and depend on provincial/territorial health authority requirements. CSC may cover the cost of some medical expenses in the community if offenders are not covered by provincial/territorial health insurance or other provincial/territorial plans (e.g., disability benefits, drug plans).
- In response: CSC will develop guidelines to obtain, track and store ID at intake; work with Canadian provinces and territories to determine how offenders can better access health care services and disability benefits following their release; and, clarify national guidelines regarding CSC payment for health services in the community.
- Increase the efficiency of health-related intake assessments processes. Health services intake assessment tools and processes are effective in identifying offender health needs; however, duplication of offender health information collected through intake assessment processes results in inefficiencies in assessing offenders' health care needs.
- In response: CSC will eliminate the requirement for repeated administration of health assessments and unnecessary repetition of health information between assessment tools. CSC will also ensure health referrals are appropriately recorded and monitored electronically.
- Ensure offenders have timely access to health education programs and harm reduction products. Health education programs, particularly those aimed at infectious disease, are associated with increased offender health-related knowledge and related behavioural changes (e.g., reduced risk-taking behaviours). Results of a review indicated that bleach was not always available as required in all CSC institutions and no recent data were available to confirm the accessibility of other harm reduction products (e.g., condoms).
- In response: CSC will provide clear direction and accountability for delivery and tracking of health education programs; monitor the distribution of harm reduction products; and, address any identified accessibility issues.
- Continue to implement and report on the Chronic Disease Management Strategy. CSC has implemented policies, guidelines and strategies to address the special health care needs of women and Indigenous offenders. Additional support related to the chronic disease needs of older offenders is required.
- In response: CSC will continue to implement the Chronic Disease Management Strategy and will report on progress against expected results to track and identify gaps in service.
This evaluation will assist CSC in improving the delivery of health services for all offenders across the continuum of care.
List of Findings
Finding 1: Need for Health Services
There is a continued need for delivery of clinical, public and mental health services to CSC offenders.
Finding 2: Alignment with Priorities and Federal Roles and Responsibilities
CSC Health Services are aligned with federal government priorities. CSC is responsible for providing health services to federal offenders, but there is an ongoing need for partnerships to effectively and efficiently deliver services to offenders.
Finding 3: Effectiveness of Health Services Intake Assessment
The overall health services intake assessment tools and processes are effective in identifying offender health needs.
Finding 4: Efficiency of Heath Services Intake Assessment Process
Duplication of offender health information collected through CSC health services intake processes and tools results in inefficiencies in assessing offenders' health care needs.
Finding 5: Access to Clinical, Public and Mental Health Care
CSC offenders have access to clinical, public, and mental health care to address their needs. The majority of offenders receive initial mental health services according to established time-frames; clinical health services are not tracked electronically. Health Services is in the process of implementing an Electronic Medical Record.
Finding 6: Access to Community Health Care Specialists
The provision of community health care specialist services for offenders for non-urgent care is subject to wait times in the community. CSC uses telemedicine (where provincial telemedicine programs are available) to address procedural issues associated with health care specialist appointments in the community. CSC does not systematically collect data regarding referrals to specialist services (in-person or telemedicine).
Finding 7: Transfers
Health services staff and offenders reported challenges to continuity of care and information sharing or documentation during transfers were identified. Inaccurate information sharing may be a result of incomplete documentation in the Health Services Transfer Summary forms.
Finding 8: Information Sharing
Some CSC personnel reported a lack of understanding of the guidelines for sharing of personal health information, and the sharing of health information could be improved. There are opportunities to implement electronic medical records to enhance information sharing.
Finding 9: Health Education Delivery
CSC's health education programs and initiatives target many of the significant health needs of the offender population, but offender access to and voluntary participation in some programs is limited.
Finding 10: Impact of Health Education and Harm Reduction Initiatives
Health education programs, particularly those aimed at infectious disease, are associated with increased offender health-related knowledge and related behavioural changes (e.g., reduced risk-taking behaviours). Results of a review indicated that bleach was not always available as required in all CSC institutions, but no recent data were available to confirm the accessibility of other harm reduction products, such as condoms, dental dams, and lubricants.
Finding 11: Institutional Mental Health Care Outcomes
Institutional mental health care provided in CSC mainstream institutions and RTCs was associated with positive impacts on offenders' behavioural stability following treatment, such as reduced likelihood of incidents, serious charges, and involuntary segregation.
Finding 12: Level of Care Based on Need
The Health Services Sector developed a Mental Health Need Scale to assess the level of mental health need and determine the appropriate level of care required in accordance with the new refined model of mental health care (primary, intermediate, psychiatric hospital). The validity and reliability of this scale have not been assessed, and electronic data on offender scale results have not been consistently recorded.
Finding 13: Regional Complex Mental Health Committees
Regional Complex Mental Health Committees have been established to assist and support institutions in providing an effective continuum of care to offenders with complex mental health needs. The degree to which funds were expended relative to those allocated at the regional level could not be accurately determined because funding was not fully tracked in the financial system.
Finding 14: Routine Discharge Planning and Offender Identification
Processes to assist offenders in obtaining provincial health cards vary across regions and are dependent on provincial/territorial health authority requirements. Procedural challenges associated with assisting offenders to obtain provincial/territorial health cards exist (e.g., prerequisite for a birth certificate, fee requirements, releases to different provinces).
Finding 15: Payment for Community Health Services
According to CSC policy, CSC may cover the cost of some medical expenses in the community if offenders are not covered by provincial/territorial health insurance or other provincial/territorial plans (e.g., disability benefits, drug plans) and have no personal means to pay. Medical expenses covered by CSC in the community vary across regions, which may be related in part to variations in provincial health coverage.
Finding 16: Community Mental Health Services and Clinical Discharge Planning
Community mental health specialists services provided to offenders were associated with lower rates of recidivism; whereas, clinical discharge planning services alone did not appear to have an impact. The number of offenders receiving clinical discharge planning services could not be determined due to inconsistencies in data recording; providing continuity of care is challenging when offenders who receive discharge planning services are released to locations with limited CSC community mental health staff.
Finding 17: Coordination of CSC's Health Services
Following changes to the health services governance structure, there has been greater standardization and integration of health services.
Finding 18: Infectious Disease Treatment: Hepatitis C Virus
CSC expenditures for Hepatitis C Virus (HCV) medication more than tripled from 2013-2014 to 2015-2016 due to a new Canadian approved standard of care. New treatment is more costly, but has resulted in an increased cure rate for individuals with the disease, also reducing the risk of spread of HCV to others.
Finding 19: Health Services for Specific Populations
CSC has implemented policies, guidelines and strategies to address the special health care needs of women and Indigenous offenders. Additional support related to the chronic disease needs of older offenders is required.
List of Recommendations
Recommendation 1: Mental Health Diversion
That CSC maintains productive relationships with partners who support individuals with mental health disorders.
Recommendation 2: Effeciency of Health Services Intake Assessment Tools and Processes
That CSC Health Services endeavour to increase the efficiency of health-related intake assessment processes by considering the following:
- Eliminating the requirement for repeated administration of health assessments;
- Optimizing and eliminating unnecessary repetition of health information between assessment tools; and,
- Ensuring health referrals are appropriately recorded and monitored.
Recommendation 3: Access to Community Health Care Specialists
That CSC Health Services collect data on wait times to access selected specialists services for non-urgent care; and implement strategies (for example increased use of telemedicine where appropriate) if wait times exceed available Canadian benchmarks.
Recommendation 4: Information Sharing
That CSC Health Services improve the understanding of information sharing requirements and limitations, as elaborated in their guidelines, in accordance with privacy laws and other relevant legislation. That CSC Health Services improve timely access to relevant and accurate medical records for Health Care staff. These will be accomplished by:
- Finalizing the implementation of electronic medical records to improve accessibility and consistency of health information;
- Enhancing awareness of information sharing procedures and "need-to-know" principle among CSC personnel, including concrete examples of where and how the principle should be applied; and
- Conducting a review of information sharing issues identified in board of investigation incidents to contribute to existing lessons learned and to inform procedural/policy changes if necessary.
Recommendation 5: Health Education and Harm Reduction
That CSC Health Services ensure that offenders have timely access to health education programs and harm reduction products by:
- Providing clear direction and accountability for delivery and tracking of health education programs; and
- Monitoring the distribution of harm reduction products (bleach, condoms, dental dams, and lubricants) and addressing any identified accessibility issues.
Recommendation 6: Level of Care Based on Need
That CSC Health Services ensure offenders are referred to the appropriate mental health services by:
- Implementing effective management practices to ensure that current information on offender level of need is recorded electronically and that previous records are retained; and
- Assessing the validity and reliability of the Mental Health Need Scale.
Recommendation 7: Regional Complex Mental Health Committees
That CSC Health Services:
- Track nationally and report on activities and expenditures of funds released to regions through RCMHCs; and
- Provide information to institutional staff regarding the role of RCMHCs and identified best practices.
Recommendation 8: Release Planning and Offender Indentification
That CSC adopt measures to address challenges related to offenders accessing health care in the community by retaining or obtaining offender ID (including health cards); and to clarify the policy, guidelines and procedures pertaining to coordinating access to medication while transitioning to the community.
- Develop guidelines to support the retention of offenders' ID including health cards;
- Establish mechanisms to obtain key ID at intake; and,
- Clarify existing release policy related to the requirements for medication at release and provide consistent communications to staff.
Recommendation 9: Access to and Payment for Community Health Services
That CSC improve access to community health services to ensure a continuum of health care for offenders during the transition to provincial/territorial health coverage, by:
- Improving partnerships with provincial and territorial health authorities to determine how offenders can better access health care services and disability benefits; and,
- Clarifying and communicating policies and procedures related to CSC's coverage (i.e., payment) for health services in the community and requirements for medication at release.
Recommendation 10: Clinical Discharge Planning and Community Mental Health Services
That CSC:
- Review the model of community mental health service delivery to ensure that community mental health services are being provided to offenders with the greatest mental health needs.
- Ensure that clinical discharge planning activities are tracked in electronic information systems.
Recommendation 11: Specific Populations of Offenders
That CSC Health Services continue to implement the Chronic Disease Management Strategy, with reference to any special needs/requirements for older, women, and Indigenous offenders, and methods for tracking impacts.
Management Action Plan Overview
In response to the recommendations identified throughout the evaluation, CSC has developed Management Action Plans to strengthen the provision of health services across the continuum of care. The Management Action Plans are summarized below, for a copy of a full plan, contact CSC's Evaluation Division.
Management Action Plan for Recommendation 1:
- Strengthen partnerships and collaborative efforts in support of the delivery of mental health services to federal offenders by guiding the implementation of CSC's Integrated Engagement Strategy.
- Share information and practices relating to mental health through the Federal Provincial Territorial Working Group on Health/Mental Health and for consideration of the Heads of Corrections.
Management Action Plan for Recommendation 2:
- Modify health services processes for health care requirements for 24-hour and 14-day assessments.
- Streamline health services intake assessment tools to reduce unnecessary repetition of physical health information.
- Review of mental health assessment tools to determine if they can be revised/streamlined to eliminate unnecessary duplication of information while maintaining effective identification of offenders with mental health needs.
- Implement a new electronic health information system to record information electronically on assessments and referrals.
Management Action Plan for Recommendation 3:
- Implement a national approach to tracking offender referrals and services for selected community specialist services.
Management Action Plan for Recommendation 4:
- Implement an Electronic Health Information System.
- Improve clarity and understanding of information sharing requirements and understanding of "need-to-know" principle (among all Health Services staff, and between Health Services and operations staff).
- Identify common issues and lessons learned, and best practices across Boards of Investigations, related to health related information sharing issues.
Management Action Plan for Recommendation 5:
- The Regional Directors Health Services and the Director General Clinical Services and Public Health are responsible for ensuring that offenders have timely access to health education programs and harm reduction products.
- Streamline and integrate delivery of health education and awareness programs to facilitate delivery and tracking.
- Monitoring harm reduction product distribution.
Management Action Plan for Recommendation 6:
- Conduct analysis to verify the validity and reliability of the Mental Health Needs Scale.
- Strengthen the process for recording and maintaining offender level of need data.
Management Action Plan for Recommendation 7:
- Implement a national approach to track and monitor outcomes associated with RCMHC activities in each region.
- Ensure accurate recording of expenditures related to RCMHCs in CSC's financial system.
Management Action Plan for Recommendation 8:
- Ensure the retention of offenders' ID (e.g., birth certificate, health card) at intake through the development of storage and tracking procedures.
- Develop guidelines and procedures to ensure that offenders obtain ID at intake (e.g., birth certificate, health card).
- Clarify existing release policy related to the requirements for medication at release and communicate the policy updates to staff.
Management Action Plan for Recommendation 9:
- Improving partnerships with provincial and territorial health authorities to remove barriers to accessing health care and disability benefits.
- Clarifying and communicating policies and procedures related to CSC's coverage (i.e., payment) for health services in the community and requirements for medication at release.
Management Action Plan for Recommendation 10:
- Review CSC's model for community mental health services.
- Ensure that clinical discharge planning activities are tracked in electronic information systems.
Management Action Plan for Recommendation 11:
- Continue to implement CSC's Chronic Disease Management Strategy.
Table of Contents
- Signatures
- Contributions
- Acknowledgments
- Executive Summary
- List of Findings
- List of Recommendations
- Management Action Plan Overview
- Table of Contents
- List of Tables
- List of Figures
- List of Acronyms
- 1.0 Introduction
- 2.0 Evaluation Method
- 3.0 Findings
- FIFE #1: Relevance of CSC's Health Services
- FIFE #2: Effectiveness and Efficiency of CSC's Health Services Intake Assessment Process
- FIFE #3: Offender Access to Care and Services
- FIFE #4: Public Health Education and Harm Reduction
- FIFE #5: Institutional Mental Health Services
- FIFE #6: Pre-Release & Community Health Services
- FIFE #7: Management & Coordination of Health Services
- 4.0 Conclusion
- Appendix A: Policy and Legislation
- Appendix B: Need for Health Services
- Appendix C: Mental Health Diversion
- Appendix D: Effectiveness of Intake Assessment for Specific Populations
- Appendix E: Description of Health Education Initiatives
- Appendix F: Institutional Mental Health Services
- Appendix G: Community Mental Health Services
- Appendix H: Clinical Discharge Planning - Roles & Responsibilities
- Appendix I: References and Supplementary Information for Specific Populations of Offenders
- References
List of Tables
- Table 1: Mainstream Institutional Mental Health Treatment – During Treatment vs. Before Treatment
- Table 2: Mainstream Institutional Mental Health Treatment – After Treatment vs. Before Treatment
- Table 3: RTC Mental Health Treatment: During Treatment vs. Before Treatment
- Table 4: RTC Mental Health Treatment: After Treatment vs. Before Treatment
- Table 5: CSC Health Services Expenditures, 2012-2013 to 2015-2016
List of Figures
- Figure 1: Percentage of Health Services staff who reported that Clinical Discharge Planners spend quite a bit or a great deal of time on the following activities
- Figure 2: Percentage of Institutional Health Services Staff who agreed that the new health services governance structure has resulted in improvements in the following areas
- Figure 3: Health Services Medication Expenditures, 2012-2013 to 2015-2016
- Figure 4: Women Offenders
- Figure 5: Indigenous Offenders
- Figure 6: Older Offenders
List of Acronyms
- ADHD
- Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
- APEC
- Aboriginal Peer Education Course
- BBSTI
- Blood Borne and Sexually Transmitted Infection
- BOI
- Boards of Investigation
- CCC
- Community Correctional Centre
- CCRA
- Corrections and Conditional Release Act
- CD
- Commissioner's Directive
- CDP
- Clinical Discharge Planning
- CHIPs
- Choosing Health in Prisons
- CMH
- Community Mental Health
- CMHI
- Community Mental Health Initiative
- CMHS
- Community Mental Health Services
- CMT
- Case Management Team
- CoMHISS
- Computerized Mental Health Screening System
- CORR
- Compliance and Operational Risk Report
- CPO
- Community Parole Officer
- CRF
- Community Residential Facility
- CSC
- Correctional Service of Canada
- DBT
- Dialectical Behaviour Therapy
- ETA
- Escorted Temporary Absence
- FASD
- Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder
- FIFE
- Finding in Focus for Evaluation
- HIV/AIDS
- Human Immunodeficiency Virus/Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome
- HCV
- Hepatitis C Virus
- HSPMR
- Health Services Performance Measurement Report
- IFMMS
- Integrated Financial and Materiel Management System
- IIS
- Intensive Intervention Strategy
- IMHT
- Institutional Mental Health Team
- IPO
- Institutional Parole Officer
- ISAPW
- Inmate Suicide Awareness and Prevention Workshop
- LTBI
- Latent Tuberculosis Infection
- MAP
- Management Action Plan
- MHNS
- Mental Health Needs Scale
- MHTS
- Mental Health Tracking System
- MMTP
- Methadone Maintenance Treatment Program
- MRSA
- Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus Aureus
- NCMHC
- National Complex Mental Health Committee
- NHQ
- National Headquarters
- OHIS-EMR
- Offender Health Information System-Electronic Medical Record
- OMS
- Offender Management System
- OST
- Opiate Substitution Therapy
- OTN
- Ontario Telemedicine Network
- PEC
- Peer Education Course
- PSR
- Psychosocial Rehabilitation
- RAP
- Reception Awareness Program
- RCMHC
- Regional Complex Mental Health Committee
- RDHS
- Regional Director of Health Services
- RHQ
- Regional Headquarters
- RTC
- Regional Treatment Centre
- SIB
- Self-Injurious Behaviour
- SLE
- Structured Living Environment
- SMT
- Suboxone Maintenance Treatment
- STI
- Sexually-Transmitted Infection
- TB
- Tuberculosis
- TBS
- Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat
- TOR
- Terms of Reference
- WebIDSS
- Web-Enabled Infectious Disease Surveillance System
- WED
- Warrant Expiry Date
1.0 Introduction
In accordance with the Five-Year Departmental Evaluation Plan, the Correctional Service of Canada (CSC) conducted an evaluation of health services. As per the Treasury Board Secretariat's (TBS) Policy on Evaluation (2009) and the Policy on Results (2016), the evaluation focused on two core objectives: 1) the continued relevance of health services, including the need for health services offered as part of the continuum of care, and their alignment with departmental and government priorities, as well as federal roles and responsibilities; and 2) CSC's performance in delivering health services, as demonstrated through implementation, effectiveness, efficiency and economy.
CSC delivers health services throughout the continuum of care including intake, incarceration and pre-release and community supervision and focuses on the areas of: mental health, public health and clinical services. By delivering efficient and effective health services, CSC encourages offenders to take responsibility for their own health, promotes healthy reintegration, and ultimately contributes to safe communities.Endnote iii These objectives are aligned with four of CSC's corporate priorities:Endnote iv
- Safe management of eligible offenders during their transition from the institution to the community, and while on supervision;
- Effective, culturally appropriate interventions for First Nations, Métis and Inuit offenders;
- Effective and timely interventions in addressing mental health needs of offenders; and,
- Efficient and effective management practices that reflect values-based leadership in a changing environment.
The results and recommendations included in this evaluation report will guide CSC's senior management with future strategic policy and decision-making regarding CSC's health services.
1.1 Background
Federal offenders experience many of the same health issues as the general Canadian population. However, compared to the Canadian population, offenders demonstrate a higher prevalence of mental health concerns (e.g., antisocial personality disorder, anxiety disorders, self-injurious behaviour) and physical health concerns (e.g., diabetes, cardiovascular conditions, HIV/AIDS, Hepatitis C).Endnote v Studies have indicated that individuals entering the correctional system already suffer from poor health due to risky lifestyle behaviours, such as intravenous drug use.Endnote vi Further, once they are incarcerated, an individual's health concerns may be aggravated.Endnote vii This may be attributed to a number of characteristics related to the institutional setting, such as shared accommodations, which may expose offenders to new physical health risks, and present opportunities for engaging in high-risk activities that may result in transmission of infectious disease.Endnote viii Moreover, CSC's offender population is aging. In 2014-15, 24% of federal offenders were 50 years or older compared to 45% of the Canadian population and the number of offenders over the age of 50 at admission has risen over the last ten years.Endnote ix With this general increase in the number of older offenders, CSC is likely to experience increased demand to address health needs attributed to aging, such as chronic conditions, cardiovascular conditions, and diabetes.Endnote x
Offenders require access to health services to meet their diverse health care needs throughout their continuum of care. Studies have shown that health services in institutions have positive impacts on offenders' health. One study demonstrated that prison health education had significant long-term effects on offenders' knowledge of the transmission of infectious diseases.Endnote xi Given that the majority of offenders will be released, their prevalent health concerns could have an impact on the communities in which they are released.Endnote xii As such, CSC's health services represent an important opportunity to address offenders' health needs.
1.2 Policy and Legislation
The delivery of health services for Canadians is a shared responsibility between the federal, provincial and territorial governments. CSC is mandated through federal legislation and corporate requirements to provide health services for federal offenders. Section 86(1) of the Corrections and Conditional Release Act (CCRA) states that CSC is obligated to provide every inmate with "essential health care; and reasonable access to non-essential mental health care that will contribute to the offender's rehabilitation and successful reintegration into the community."Endnote xiii
In addition to the CCRA, CSC is guided by a series of internal Commissioner's Directives (CDs) that support legislative obligations. CDs specific to health services include the following:Footnote 1
- CD 800 – Health Services: focuses on procedures related to health services delivery, including assessments occurring at intake, responsibilities during medical emergency situations, involuntary admission and treatment at Regional Treatment Centres and childbirth arrangements for pregnant offenders.
- CD 843 – Management of Inmate Self-Injurious and Suicidal Behaviour: outlines procedures for assigning suicide watch observational levels, including screening for the risk of suicide, descriptions of high and modified suicide watch and mental health monitoring. Also included are procedures for the use of restraint equipment including reporting requirements, application to pregnant offenders and assessment and monitoring.
- CD 578 – Intensive Intervention Strategy in Women's Institutions: provides procedures for Structured Living Environments (SLEs) including admission requirements, assessments, use of the therapeutic quiet room, discharge process and outreach support. The Secure Unit procedures are also presented, including rules and expectations, the role of interdisciplinary teams, treatment planning and movement.
1.3 Program Description
According to the National Essential Health Services Framework, health services are defined as physical and mental health services, which include health promotion, disease prevention, health maintenance, patient education, diagnosis and treatment of illnesses. In accordance with CSC's program structure, health services are delivered in three areas:Endnote xiv
- Clinical Services: "assessment, diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic physical illnesses."
- Public Health: "services and resources on a variety of topics (mental health, wellness, infectious diseases, etc.) provided to inmates related to health promotion and education; disease prevention, control and management of infectious diseases and discharge planning for community reintegration."
- Mental Health: "assessment, intervention, treatment and support services and discharge planning provided to inmates with mental health needs in the areas of emotion, thinking and/or behaviour."
1.3.1 Intake Activities
During the intake process, offenders undergo health needs assessments, screening and testing and intervention for immediate mental, clinical and public health care needs. Offenders are also provided with disease prevention initiatives along with health promotion and educational activities. Ongoing surveillance and analysis of offender health needs is initiated at intake and continues throughout incarceration.
1.3.2 Incarceration Activities
As per CSC's mandate, essential health services are provided to offenders during incarceration. This includes ongoing screening and assessment as required, and various mental, clinical, and public health interventions. Disease prevention measures, health promotion and education, as well as surveillance and analysis of offender health needs, which were initiated at intake, continue throughout the incarceration period.
Mental Health Services: A range of institutional programs and services are available to address offenders' mental health needs. Primary mental health services consist of individual and group interventions (e.g., sleep hygiene, stress management, counselling), as well as crisis intervention as needed. Offenders who require intermediate mental health care may access high or moderate intensity levels of service, women offenders may also access the SLE. Offenders with acute needs that cannot be addressed within the institution may receive treatment at a RTC.
Clinical Services: Offenders are offered primary care (e.g., dental services, pharmacy services) and chronic disease management. Offenders also have access to community specialists if necessary. In addition, CSC offers infectious disease management including the opiate substitution therapy (OST) program which is made available to offenders with substance abuse problems.
Public Health Services: CSC provides a number of public health educational activities to address infectious diseases, such as the Peer Education Course (PEC), which aims to train offenders as peer counsellors and to provide information on infectious diseases. Offenders may also access harm reduction initiatives (e.g., needle exchange programs, bleach kits, condoms).
1.3.3 Pre-Release and Community Activites
During pre-release, CSC provides routine discharge planning to prepare offenders for transitions in care, including release to the community.Footnote 2 Offenders with significant mental health needs may be referred for clinical discharge planning. This process aims to ensure that offenders receive continuity of care by establishing comprehensive plans and transitional services.
In the community, CSC offers essential physical health services for offenders residing in Community Correctional Centres (CCCs) where provincial coverage is unavailable. This may include appointments, dental care, eyewear, and/or equipment and medical devices. In some regions, CSC may provide additional coverage for medication. CSC provides limited community mental health services in select locations to provide support for offenders with significant mental health needs. These services are provided by mental health professionals, and may include monitoring and assessment, education, clinical accompaniment support, mobile services, and community capacity building.
2.0 Evaluation Method
2.1 Scope of the Evaluation
The scope of the evaluation was determined through a number of activities aimed at identifying evaluation priorities, including:
- Pre-evaluation consultations with approximately 80 CSC key informants from National Headquarters (NHQ), Regional Headquarters (RHQ), institutions and the community. Consultations were conducted in person, by telephone or by videoconference.
- Site visits were conducted at Millhaven Institution and Joyceville Institution to gain a better understanding of the intake assessment process from health services staff members.
- Review of documentation including CSC priorities and risks as well as research, audit, evaluation, accreditation and other performance reports.
- Risk was assessed at the outset with mental health services representing the highest area of risk for the organization, primarily due to the direct link with corporate risk and priorities and the high sensitivity of this area.
The scope of the evaluation was further refined through ongoing consultations with the Office of Primary Interest (OPI), the Health Services Sector, and key stakeholders which assisted in organizing the health services evaluation into three periods: intake, incarceration and pre-release and community supervision. These three periods reflect the continuum of care provided to offenders by CSC and examines clinical, public and mental health services. A brief description of each period is provided below.
2.1.1 Intake
The evaluation questions related to intake concentrated on intake screenings and assessment tools, as well as specific health services interventions, health promotion activities, and access to health information. The continued need for CSC health services, alignment with government priorities and federal roles and responsibilities were also explored. Specific questions were included in regards to meeting the health care needs of women offenders, Indigenous offenders and older offenders at intake.
2.1.2 Incarceration
The evaluation questions associated with incarceration examined the integration and continuity of health care services, including any challenges or improvements with the new governance structure, health services planning and coordination, and gaps related to accessing health care professionals and health promotion activities. Specific questions were included related to meeting the needs of women offenders, Indigenous offenders and older offenders during incarceration.
2.1.3 Pre-Release and Community Supervision
The evaluation questions for pre-release and community supervision focused on routine and clinical discharge planning and community mental health services. Challenges in regards to offender identification and payment for essential health services were also examined. Specific questions were included in regards to meeting the health care needs of women offenders, Indigenous offenders and older offenders during pre-release and community supervision.
2.2 Approach
The evaluation of CSC's health services used a mixed-method research design, incorporating both quantitative and qualitative methodologies. Several lines of evidence were used to address the evaluation issues and questions, including:
2.2.1 Literature and Document Review
An extensive examination of peer-reviewed literature and internal and external documents was conducted, including:
- CSC and other governmental documents and reports (e.g., legislation, policies and regulations, evaluation reports, research reports, audit reports, board of investigations, and other corporate and operational documents);
- A review of Canadian public health initiatives;
- A review of community health roles and responsibilities;
- A review of the prevalence of health issues in the Canadian population and in the offender population;
- A review of the methods of diversion for mental health needs from the criminal justice system; and,
- An environmental scan of health services in other correctional jurisdictions.
2.2.2 Qualitative DataFootnote 3
Interviews with Offenders: Intake and Incarceration
Offender interviews for intake and incarceration were conducted during institutional visits between November 2014 and January 2015. An interview guide was developed using open-ended and closed-ended questions (such as 5-point Likert-scales, dichotomous and categorical multiple choice questions). Criteria to participate in the intake questionnaire included offenders who were admitted to CSC within the previous 3 to 12 months. The criteria for the incarceration questionnaire included offenders who were incarcerated for a minimum of 15 months or more at CSC at the time of the evaluation. In total, 104 offenders participated in the intake interviews and 149 offenders participated in the incarceration interviews.
The data collected through both questionnaires was entered into Snap Survey software and exported into SPSS and Microsoft Excel. The Evaluation team analyzed qualitative data obtained through open-ended questions using the iterative and inductiveFootnote 4 process to identify relevant themes. Qualitative data obtained through closed-ended questions were analyzed using descriptive analysis techniques. Frequencies and percentages were calculated based on the number of valid responses to the questions.
Interviews with Offenders: Regional Treatment Centre
Offender interviews were conducted at RTCs located in the Quebec and Prairie regions between January 26 and 29, 2015. An interview guide was developed using open- and closed-ended questions (dichotomous questions and one categorical multiple choice question). In total, 32 offenders participated in the interviews. They were incarcerated for a minimum of 2 months to a maximum of 108 months.
Electronic Questionnaires with Staff
Four electronic questionnaires were developed using Snap Survey software and administered through CSC's Intranet site (InfoNet). The questionnaires solicited the views and experiences of health services and non-health services staff in regards to the delivery of health services to offenders throughout the continuum of care. Respondents were representative of all security levels, regions, genders, and facilities across Canada. In addition, an electronic consultation was developed using Microsoft Word and was sent through Outlook. Data were analyzed using the same process and procedures as used for the offender interviews.
Intake and Incarceration
- Intake: this questionnaire was launched in October 2014 and solicited responses from health services staff and managers involved in the delivery of health services during intake. A total of 116 participants responded,Footnote 5 all regions participated in the questionnaire.
- Incarceration: this questionnaire was launched in August 2015 and solicited responses of health services staff members involved in the delivery of health services to offenders during the incarceration period. A total of 196 participants respondedFootnote 6 with representation from all regions across CSC.
- General Staff – Incarceration and Intake: this questionnaire was launched in July 2015 and solicited responses pertaining to general staff and management experiences with health care services during incarceration. A total of 167 participants responded,Footnote 7 all regions participated in the questionnaire.
Pre-Release and Community Supervision
- Pre-Release and Community Supervision: this questionnaire was launched in August 2016 and solicited responses from institutional and community health services staff as well as managers involved in the delivery of health services to offenders at pre-release and during community supervision. A total of 291 participants responded,Footnote 8 all regions participated in the questionnaire.
- Regional Directors, Health Services: this consultation was launched in August 2016 and solicited responses from Regional Directors respecting the responsibilities and processes related to offender provincial health cards, payment of fees and essential health services coverage. All regions participated in the consultation.
2.2.3 Quantitative Data
Automated data
Various sources of automated data were used for the Evaluation, such as:
- Offender Data: Data pertaining to mental health referrals, assessments, and services were obtained from the Computerized Health Intake Screening System (CoMHISS) and the Mental Health Tracking System (MHTS) and analyzed using Statistical Analysis System (SAS) software. Additional data related to sub-population profiles, offender characteristics and correctional outcomes (e.g., institutional incidents) were extracted from the Offender Management System (OMS) and analyzed using SAS.
- Human Resource Data: Data extracted from the Human Resource Management System (HRMS) database were provided by CSC's Human Resources Management Section. Data on staff classifications, positions and location, as well as data specific to Aboriginal perceptions training were retrieved for FY 2014 to 2016.
- Financial Data: Financial data for health services expenditures was retrieved from the Integrated Financial & Material Management System (IFMMS) for FY 2012-13 to 2015-16 and were analyzed using Excel.
2.3 Measures
Analysis of Qualitative Data
The following scale was used throughout the current report to indicate the weight of emerging qualitative themesFootnote 9 and to facilitate the interpretation of evaluation results.
- A few/a small number of interviewees = less than 25%;
- Some interviewees = 25% to 45%;
- About half of interviewees = 46% to 55%;
- Many interviewees = 56% to 75%;
- Most interviewees = over 75%; and,
- Almost all interviewees = 95% or more.
2.4 Limitations and Mitigation Strategies
Evaluations face constraints that may have implications for the validity and reliability of the evaluations findings and recommendations. The following table outlines the limitations encountered along with the impact experienced and the mitigation strategies put in place to ensure decision makers have confidence in the evaluation findings and recommendations.
Limitation | Impact | Mitigation Strategy |
---|---|---|
Missing or unreliable data (e.g., health referrals, wait times, program participation, level of need, financial expenditures, offender identification, clinical discharge planning activities). | Inability to report on the effectiveness, efficiency and/or economy of the health services evaluation. | Unreliable data was excluded from our analyses and recommendations were made to track and record pertinent information. |
Sample size too small to conduct analyses and/or draw conclusions:
| Comprehensive information for specific populations of offenders is not complete. Inability to analyze the effectiveness and efficiency of services for specific populations (e.g., women and Indigenous offenders) independently. | Older offender health requirements and services were assessed in other components of the evaluation where possible (e.g., health services for specific populations). Women and Indigenous offenders were included in the overall analyses. |
Correctional outcomes (e.g., institutional incidents) could be the result of time passing (i.e., outcomes more likely to occur later in an offender's sentence) or participation in mental health treatment. | Difficult to determine the construct validity of the analysis. | A random sample of offenders was selected as a comparison group and arbitrary treatment timelines were implemented to compare results. |
During mental health treatment, offenders may demonstrate heightened emotional instability, resulting in correctional outcomes (i.e., institutional incidents). | Difficult to determine if treatment has any significant impact on correctional outcomes during treatment. | Results will be presented to identify that outcomes during treatment are to be interpreted with caution. |
A small number of RTC interviews were completed. | Experiences reported only represent a small subset of the population. | Other lines of evidence were used to substantiate and provide further information on data received in interviews. |
4.0 Conclusion
The concept of universality respecting health care is outlined in the Canada Health Act,Endnote ccix this means that all Canadians are entitled to access health care in accordance with the health insurance plan of their respective province; in the case of federally incarcerated persons, CSC provides access to health care.
The evaluation found that CSC Health Services are relevant and meet the needs of federal offenders. Positive impacts were found regarding institutional mental health care where offenders had a reduced likelihood of incidents, serious charges and involuntary segregation following treatment. Several key areas were identified for service improvements, such as:
- Access to institutional health services, for example limited access to some health education programs, bleach kits and community health care specialists;
- Effectiveness and efficiency of the health services intake assessment process, for example duplication of offender health information through intake processes and tools;
- Gaps in policy and procedures to support offenders in obtaining necessary ID required to transition from CSC health services to provincial and territorial health services upon release; and
- Missing or unreliable data among referrals to specialist services (in person or telemedicine), clinical health services information and the mental health needs scale.
This evaluation will assist CSC in improving the delivery of health services for all offenders across the continuum of care.
Appendix A: Policy and Legislation
A list of Commissioner's Directives that involve a health related component includes:
- CD 705: Intake Assessment Process and Correctional Plan Framework
- CD 705-3: Immediate Needs Identification and Admission Interviews
- CD 702: Aboriginal Offenders
- CD 566-12: Personal Property of Offenders
- CD 860: Offender's Money
Appendix B: Need for Health Services
Clinical Health Needs
Men OffendersEndnote ccx
- 34% of male offenders self-reported head injuries, whereas 19% suffer from back pain, and 15% have asthma. With respect to head-injuries, the prevalence pertains to any current or history of head injuries, and may therefore include a broad range of injuries. A review of health files found that 2% of offenders had evidence of recent brain injury.Endnote ccxi
- The rates of many chronic conditions (e.g. high blood pressure, high cholesterol, angina, arthritis, etc.) are significantly higher for men offenders over the age of 50 years compared to men offenders under 50 years of age.
- A significantly higher proportion of men offenders have asthma (15%) compared to men in the Canadian population (7%).
- Indigenous peoples in the Canadian population have an increased risk of developing cardiovascular disease,Endnote ccxii and they comprise a disproportionately high percentage of the incarcerated population (compared to the general population).
- Indigenous men offenders have significantly higher rates of head injuries (43%) than non-Indigenous men offenders (32%).
Women OffendersEndnote ccxiii
- According to self-reports, 26% of women offenders suffer from back pain followed by head injuries (23%), menopause (19%) and asthma (16%).
- A higher proportion of older women offenders have conditions affecting their cardiovascular system (47%) and they also have a higher prevalence of diabetes (17%) compared to younger women offenders (15%; 4%).
- Compared to the Canadian women population (10%), a higher proportion of women offenders (16%) have asthma.
- A higher proportion of Indigenous women offenders compared to non-Indigenous women offenders have health conditions affecting their central nervous systems (29%; 25%), diabetes (11%; 3%) and ulcers (11%; 6%).
Public Health NeedsFootnote 148
The most prevalent public health issues self-reported by men and women offenders are identified below.
Men OffendersEndnote ccxiv
According to self-reports:
- HCV (9%) and HIV (1%) are the most prevalent communicable diseases among an admission cohort of federal men offenders.
- Indigenous men offenders have a significantly higher prevalence of HCV (16%) and HIV (2%) than non-Indigenous men offenders (HCV 8%, HIV 1%).
- Men offenders over 50 years of age have a higher prevalence of HCV (13%) and HIV (2%) in comparison to men offenders under 50 years of age (HCV 9%; HIV 1%).
Women OffendersEndnote ccxv
According to self-reports:
- Among an admission cohort of women offenders, the most prevalent self-reported public health issues were HCV and HIV/AIDS (20%).Footnote 149
- In addition, the prevalence of HCV and HIV/AIDS was higher among Indigenous women offenders (27%) than non-Indigenous women offender counterparts (17%).
- Older women offenders have a slightly higher prevalence of HCV and HIV/AIDS (22%) relative to younger women offenders (20%).
Mental Health Needs
Men Offenders
- Common mental disorders among men offenders were: antisocial personality disorder (44%), anxiety disorders (30%), mood disorders (17%), and major mental illness (12%), which includes major depressive disorder, bi-polar I and II disorders, or any psychotic disorder.Footnote 150, Endnote ccxvi
- Indigenous men offenders had higher rates of personality disorders compared to non-Indigenous men offenders with the most pronounced differences being antisocial personality disorder (60% and 40% respectively) and borderline personality disorder (22% and 14% respectively).Footnote 151, Endnote ccxvii
- Men offenders did not engage in self-injurious behaviour (SIB) as frequently as women offenders; however, their SIB are more likely to result in minor and serious injury compared to women offenders whose incidents of SIB are more likely to result in no significant injury.Endnote ccxviii
Women Offenders
- The vast majority of women offenders had a psychiatric disorder at some point in their lives. Among the most common were: lifetime prevalence of antisocial personality disorder (83%); experience of a major depressive episode, a type of mood disorder, at some point in their lives (69%), and post-traumatic stress disorder, a type of anxiety disorder, in the past year (31%).Footnote 152 Borderline personality disorder was more common in women offenders than in men offenders.Endnote ccxix
- Twenty-two percent of women offenders had attempted suicide prior to being admitted to CSC.Endnote ccxx
- Indigenous women offenders experienced higher occurrences of conduct disorder than their non-Indigenous women counterparts (64% and 42% respectively).Endnote ccxxi
- Although women offenders accounted for 5% of CSC's incarcerated population, they comprised 12% of the offenders who had a SIB incident and accounted for 32% of all SIB incidents. Furthermore, Indigenous women offenders engaged in twice as many incidents of SIB compared to non-Indigenous women.Endnote ccxxii
Appendix C: Mental Health Diversion
Pre-contact with the criminal justice system – crime prevention:
Focus on preventing individuals with mental health needs from coming into contact with the criminal justice system through intervention on risk factors before crime happens.
Post-contact with the criminal justice system – Sequential Intercept ModelEndnote ccxxiii
- First interactions with law enforcement and emergency services: the goal at this stage of diversion is to divert individuals with mental health needs from arrest by providing alternative treatment options and to decrease risk of harm resulting from these interactions.
There are four models of police-based diversion in Canada:- Crisis Intervention Teams (CIT) – interdisciplinary community liaison teams;
- Psychiatric Emergency Response Teams (PERT) – police officers are paired with licensed mental health professionals;
- Crisis Mobile Teams (CMT) – behavioural mental health specialists assist police officers in situations involving persons with mental disorders; and
- Informal police diversion – police may refer an individual to community mental health services in lieu of charges (generally for less serious acts or on first-arrest).
- Post-arrest (pre-trial): this type of diversion interrupts the standard prosecution process, it occurs between the individual's arrest and their appearance in court. Offenders are diverted from the criminal justice system and referred for treatment or other specialized diversion programs.
There are four elements of the process:- Appointment of counsel;
- Assessment of the offender;
- Consultation with the victim; and,
- Prosecutorial review of charges and possible diversion. This type of diversion can be requested on behalf of the individual with the mental health need by the defence counsel, crown counsel, police, mental health services, diversion programs, citizens, etc.
- Court-based diversion : designed to divert individuals with mental health needs through mental health courts, mental health dockets, or traditional courts with alternative sentencing planning strategies to a judicially monitored diversion program. The focus is on community-based treatment and restorative remedial measures versus prosecution, and may involve a multidisciplinary team (e.g., judge, crown attorneys, mental health workers).
- Re-entry planning from jails, prisons, and forensic hospitalization : does not specifically focus on diversion per se; rather, it focuses on continuity of care and successful reintegration (or re-entry) into the community. Preparation for reintegration should begin prior to release. Post release, interventions should support offenders' transition from the prison to the community and help maintain gains made in treatment while incarcerated.
- Community corrections and community support : the goal is to divert individuals with mental health needs under community supervision from re-entering the criminal justice system.
Best practices include:- Mental health screening;
- Managing treatment conditions and technical violations through the use of non-traditional methods that emphasize non-custodial alternatives;
- Use of intensive and specialized case management; and,
- Use of a specialized caseload model (e.g., Have a set of dedicated officers for offenders with mental disorders, reduce officers caseload (typically one third of a traditional caseload); provide officers with sustained training on mental health and other related issues; have officers intervene with offenders directly and coordinate community services)
Sequential Intercept Model Notes
Intercept 1: First interactions with law enforcement and emergency services
Evidence suggests that diversion at this intercept can increase referrals to mental health resources, increase the number of days spent in the community, and reduce the use of force in police interactions with mentally ill offenders.Endnote ccxxiv More generally, however, the research in this area is limited and further evaluation is needed before firm conclusion can be drawn about the effectiveness of mental health diversion at this intercept.
Intercept 2: Post-arrest (pre-trial)
Generally, diverted offenders at this intercept have more time in the community, greater treatment participation, fewer hospital days in the community, fewer arrests (1 year follow-up), less homelessness (1-year follow-up), and more emergency room contacts.Endnote ccxxv It is noted that this research needs to be interpreted with caution due to a small number of studies, differing methodology, and variability in what was considered to be a 'diversion' program.Endnote ccxxvi
Intercept 3: Court Based Diversion
The purpose of mental health courts is to target the root causes of crime committed by individuals with mental health needs (e.g., untreated mental illness) and to help prevent mentally disordered individuals from reoffending. Mental health courts have been associated with fewer arrests and jail days (e.g., an average of 3 days instead of 23 days), reduced recidivism, and lower costs over time (relative to traditional courts.Endnote ccxxvii Further, mental health courts better linked individuals to mental health services and those individuals were more like to stay in a higher level of treatment than individuals not participating in a mental health court program.Endnote ccxxviii
Mental health dockets refer to dedicating a period of time during traditional court (e.g., one afternoon per week) to individuals with mental health needs.
Intercept 4: Re-entry planning from jails, prisons, and forensic hospitalization
Preparation for reintegration (or re-entry) into the community should begin prior to release. Good practice suggests that post-release interventions should support offenders' transition from the prison to the community and help maintain gains made in treatment while incarcerated.Endnote ccxxix This recommendation is in line with CSC's Mental Health Strategy which suggests "dedicated services are required to support a seamless continuity of care from the community to the correctional system and upon return to the community" for offenders with mental health needs.Endnote ccxxx
Intercept 5: Community corrections and community support
Offenders with mental health issues can have trouble complying with their conditions, placing them at higher risk for technical violations, new offences, and new sentences. Revocation prevention strategies include: incentives for compliance with conditions (e.g., reduce frequency of reporting); graduated scheme of responses before employing the most serious response (i.e., revocation of probation/parole); consult with treatment providers before taking action on a violation related to treatment/mental health evaluation and consider treatment alternatives (e.g., refer to more intensive treatment); respond to minor technical violations early to prevent more serious technical violations, establishing agreements and guidelines with service providers regarding the support that they will provide and the actions that will be taken for failure to participate in treatment; and, have mental health professionals help offenders better understand the consequences of their behaviour in terms of sanctions.Endnote ccxxxi
CSC Community Mental Health Specialist services follow an assertive community treatment model in that multidisciplinary teams of professionals provide mentally ill offenders with services tailored to their needs in the community and share responsibility for the offender.Endnote ccxxxii Generally assertive community treatment based programs (relative to 'treatment as usual') were found to be associated with "better criminal justice outcomes (e.g., any conviction, mean jail time), better improvement of substance abuse problems, and improvement in global functioning and economic self-sufficiency".Endnote ccxxxiii
Appendix D: Effectiveness of Intake Assessment for Specific Populations
Indigenous Offenders
- Most health services staff members and Indigenous offenders did not report any barriers specific to this sub-population of offenders in completing health status intake assessments.Footnote 153
- Those health services staff members who did identify challenges reported that there were communication or cultural barriers in completing intake assessments for Indigenous offenders (n=10).
- Many health services staff members reported that Indigenous offenders interested in following a traditional healing path, "never" or "rarely" had an Elder involved in completing intake assessment tools.Footnote 154
- Most (78%, n=18) Indigenous offenders interested in following a traditional health path reported that they did not have an Elder present during health intake assessments, but many (n = 11) reported it would have been helpful.Footnote 155
- Indigenous offenders are equally as likely to receive intake assessments (i.e., 24-hour and 14-day) within the appropriate timeframe compared to the whole offender population (Indigenous and non-Indigenous offenders).Footnote 156, Endnote ccxxxiv
Visible Minority Offenders
- MostFootnote 157 health services staff members reported that they did not face any challenges completing intake assessments for visible minority offenders.
- Among those who did report challenges, it was noted that there were communication or cultural barriers in completing intake assessments for visible minority offenders (n=15).
Older Offenders
- Most health services staff members and older offenders did not report any challenges specific to this sub-population of offenders in completing health status intake assessments.Footnote 158
- Some (44%, n=7) older offenders reported having additional health care needs including physical health concerns (e.g., knee pain, osteoarthritis) and other health issues (e.g., heart difficulties, hearing problems, diabetes, and cancer).
- Of those older offenders who indicated that they had additional health care needs, about half reported that the health services intake assessment screening tool did not identify their age-related health needs (n=4).Footnote 159
Women Offenders
- Most health services staff members and women offenders did not report any challenges completing intake assessments for women offenders.Footnote 160
- Women offenders are equally as likely (or more so) to receive the 24-hour assessment, 14-day assessment, and CoMHISS within the appropriate timeframe compared to the whole offender population (women and men offenders).Footnote 161, Endnote ccxxxv
Appendix E: Description of Health Education Initiatives
Reception Awareness Program (RAP):
- RAP is offered to all newly admitted offenders at reception; however, attendance is voluntary.Endnote ccxxxvi Separate versions of the program are developed and delivered for men and women to address their specific health care needs. RAP provides general information on infectious diseases, harm reduction measures, and related health services and programs offered by CSC.Footnote 162, Endnote ccxxxvii
Peer Education Course/Aboriginal Peer Education Course (PEC/APEC):
- CSC offers PEC and APEC, which are one week training programsEndnote ccxxxviii offered to offender volunteers who want to become PEC/APEC support workers to other offenders.Endnote ccxxxix PEC includes a series of modules dealing with infectious diseases and the provision of peer support to offenders infected and affected by these diseases.Endnote ccxl Similarly, APEC is a one week culturally sensitive training course offered to offender volunteers who want to provide peer support to offenders within the context of the Indigenous culture.Endnote ccxli The goal of APEC is to learn the basic facts of infectious diseases in order to support encourage and empower Indigenous peers to sustain behavioural and lifestyle changes.Endnote ccxlii After participating in the PEC/APEC training program, offenders can be selected to work as Peer Support workers within their institutions. Offenders in need of health service support can than request the services offered through a PEC/APEC support worker.
Inmate Suicide Awareness and Prevention Workshop (ISAPW):
- The ISAPW is a three-hour workshop that provides offenders information about suicide including: suicide facts and myths, possible stressors to suicide, signs and symptoms of suicide risk and what to do if someone is thinking about suicide.Endnote ccxliii The program is delivered by personnel from chaplaincy, nursing, programs, and/or volunteers.Endnote ccxliv Commissioner's Directive 843: Management of Inmate Self-Injurious and Suicidal Behaviour highlights the importance of having the Inmate Suicide Awareness and Prevention Workshop available on a regular basis and providing offenders access to the workshop.Endnote ccxlv CSC aims to deliver this workshop at reception centers in an effort to provide the training to all offenders.Endnote ccxlvi
Health Services factsheets:
- Health Services offers monthly health promotion and infectious disease prevention factsheets and PowerPoint presentations. The factsheets address specific areas of health concerns, including infectious diseases, chronic conditions, mental health, and general healthy living. Topics may inform on HIV/AIDS, diabetes, TB, heart disease, suicide prevention, and substance abuse.
Appendix F: Institutional Mental Health Services
Mainstream Institutional Mental Health Treatment
95% Confidence Interval | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Variables | B | HR | Lower | Upper |
Incidents: All | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.04070 | 0.960 | 0.863 | 1.068 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.09101 | 0.913* | 0.836 | 0.997 |
Incidents: Behaviour | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.04524 | 1.046 | 0.854 | 1.281 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.07826 | 0.925 | 0.794 | 1.077 |
Minor Charges | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.02530 | 1.026 | 0.897 | 1.173 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.06023 | 0.942 | 0.836 | 1.060 |
Serious Charges | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.12578 | 0.882 | 0.727 | 1.070 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.35008 | 0.705*** | 0.602 | 0.825 |
Involuntary Segregation | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.13634 | 0.873* | 0.769 | 0.990 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.38467 | 0.681*** | 0.605 | 0.765 |
National Correctional Program Completions | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.17865 | 1.196*** | 1.078 | 1.327 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.20870 | 1.232*** | 1.122 | 1.352 |
Education Course/Credit Completion | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.02233 | 1.023 | 0.901 | 1.160 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.29131 | 1.338*** | 1.188 | 1.508 |
* p.<.05; **p < .01; ***p<.001. The log-likelihood test for all models were significant as a whole (i.e., p< .0001) Each model controlled for risk, need, motivation, reintegration potential, age, gender, and Indigenous status. Time interactions were also implemented for variables that violated the proportional hazards assumption. The significance values for the hazard ratios were corrected for dependence using the modified sandwich estimator (Allison, 2010). Assault-related incidents, self-harm, and voluntary segregation are not included due to low number of offenders who experienced that event. |
Mainstream Institutional Mental Health Treatment: Indigenous Offenders
95% Confidence Interval | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Variables | B | HR | Lower | Upper |
Incidents: All | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.02019 | 0.980 | 0.795 | 1.207 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.07465 | 0.928 | 0.784 | 1.098 |
Incidents: Behaviour | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.00847 | 0.992 | 0.686 | 1.434 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.24882 | 0.780 | 0.580 | 1.048 |
Minor Charges | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.00244 | 0.998 | 0.807 | 1.234 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.07810 | 0.925 | 0.751 | 1.139 |
Serious Charges | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.06992 | 0.932 | 0.639 | 1.360 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.20298 | 0.816 | 0.639 | 1.043 |
Involuntary Segregation | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.12117 | 0.886 | 0.700 | 1.122 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.35983 | 0.698** | 0.555 | 0.877 |
National Correctional Program Completions | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.32006 | 1.377** | 1.137 | 1.668 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.26252 | 1.300** | 1.090 | 1.551 |
Education Course/Credit Completion | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.00478 | 0.995 | 0.804 | 1.233 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.20521 | 1.228* | 1.002 | 1.505 |
* p.<.05; **p < .01; ***p<.001. The log-likelihood test for all models were significant as a whole (i.e., p< .0001) Each model controlled for risk, need, motivation, reintegration potential, age, gender, and Indigenous status. Time interactions were also implemented for variables that violated the proportional hazards assumption. The significance values for the hazard ratios were corrected for dependence using the modified sandwich estimator (Allison, 2010). Assault-related incidents, self-harm, and voluntary segregation are not included due to low number of offenders who experienced that event. |
RTC Mental Health Treatment
95% Confidence Interval | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Variables | B | HR | Lower | Upper |
Incidents: All | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.19464 | 1.215*** | 1.087 | 1.358 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.21539 | 0.806*** | 0.714 | 0.911 |
Incidents: Assault | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.38367 | 1.468** | 1.141 | 1.887 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.34242 | 0.710* | 0.541 | 0.933 |
Incidents: Behaviour | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.27319 | 1.314** | 1.099 | 1.571 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.23994 | 0.787* | 0.654 | 0.947 |
Incidents: Self-Harm | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.04428 | 1.045 | 0.799 | 1.368 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.41555 | 0.660* | 0.454 | 0.959 |
Minor Charges | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.23779 | 0.788 | 0.605 | 1.027 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.05286 | 0.949 | 0.679 | 1.324 |
Serious Charges | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.36885 | 0.692** | 0.524 | 0.912 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.37151 | 0.690*** | 0.554 | 0.859 |
Involuntary Segregation | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.49070 | 0.612*** | 0.513 | 0.731 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.20673 | 0.813** | 0.695 | 0.951 |
National Correctional Program Completions | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.22237 | 0.801 | 0.565 | 1.135 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.05852 | 1.060 | 0.824 | 1.364 |
Education Course/Credit Completion | ||||
During Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | -0.28018 | 0.756 | 0.548 | 1.041 |
After Treatment (vs. Before Treatment) | 0.05759 | 1.059 | 0.776 | 1.445 |
* p.<.05; **p < .01; ***p<.001. The log-likelihood test for all models were significant as a whole (i.e., p< .0001) Each model controlled for risk, need, motivation, reintegration potential, age, gender, and Indigenous status. Time interactions were also implemented for variables that violated the proportional hazards assumption. The significance values for the hazard ratios were corrected for dependence using the modified sandwich estimator (Allison, 2010). Voluntary segregation is not included due to low number of offenders who experienced that event. |
Appendix G: Community Mental Health Services
Table 1: Recidivism Outcomes for Men and Women CMHI and non-CMHI Participants
Men | Women | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
n (%) | N | n (%) | N | |
CMHS services | 74 (30%) | 249 | 9 (27%) | 33 |
CDP services | 34 (52%) | 65 | 6 (43%) | 14 |
CDP/CMHS | 27 (43%) | 63 | 3 (17%) | 18 |
Non-CMHS | 138 (51%) | 269 | 19 (33%) | 58 |
Men | Women | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
n (%) | N | n (%) | N | |
CMHS services | 90 (36%) | 249 | 10 (30%) | 33 |
CDP services | 38 (59%) | 65 | 7 (50%) | 14 |
CDP/CMHS | 32 (51%) | 63 | 5 (28%) | 18 |
Non-CMHS | 165 (61%) | 269 | 27 (47%) | 58 |
Source: MacDonald, S. F., Stewart, L. A., & Feely, S. (2014). The impact of the Community Mental Health Initiative (CMHI) (R-337). Ottawa, ON.
Appendix H: Clinical Discharge Planning - Roles & Responsibilities
The clinical discharge planning process involves coordination among several key staff members whose level of involvement varies according to the offender's health needs.
Roles and responsibilities of clinical discharge planning
The Discharge Planning Matrix Tool,Footnote 163 the Discharge Planning and Transfer Guidelines, and the Integrated Mental Health Guidelines outline the roles and responsibilities for CSC staff in relation to CDP.Endnote ccxlvii
- The clinical discharge planner is responsible for the following in relation to CDP caseload offenders:Endnote ccxlviii
- Developing discharge/integration plans (i.e., Mental Health Assessment for Clinical Discharge in accordance with the content guidelines for Mental Health Assessment and Treatment/Intervention Plans) that include referrals and follow-ups in the various areas such as Housing; Identification; Community Support; Spiritual/Religious/Cultural/Ethnic, etc.
- Providing the IPO/Community Parole Officer with information for reference in the completion of the Correctional Plan Update, Community Strategy and to assist with other release decision making processes – in accordance with case management timelines.
- Setting up necessary appointments and medication follow up appointments prior to release.
- The clinical discharge planner is also responsible for the following:
- Providing brief interventions for offenders when referral for services are two months or less prior to release date or WED; or to address specific needs (e.g., referral to a psychiatrist).Endnote ccxlix
- Responding to referrals for consultation in complex cases.Endnote ccl
- The institutional parole officer, as part of offender case preparation is responsible for the following in relation to collaboration and communication with Health Services:
- Submits referral request to Health Services for a consultation to clinical discharge planners.Endnote ccli
- Informs Health Services of upcoming case preparation in advance of 6 months before hearing or release.Endnote cclii
- Informs Health Services of upcoming release 3 weeks in advance (or as soon as possible for last minute releases).Endnote ccliii
- Prompts pre-release case-conference prior to release if significant change is shared in the GIST report provided by Health Services prior to release.Endnote ccliv
- The institutional parole officer, is also responsible for the following in relation to managing offender health information:Endnote cclv
- Includes the relevant Health Services information in the Correctional Plan.
- Ensures the Health Status at Discharge: Gist Reports are placed in the offender Case Management file.
- Assists offenders to obtain a provincial health card in the province of the offender's releasing institution, or when an offender is being released to a different province, assists the offender to apply for temporary provincial health coverage in the province of incarceration.Endnote cclvi
- The community parole officer, in preparation for an offender's release to the community, is responsible for the following:Endnote cclvii
- Develops the community release strategy in collaboration with the IPO and the clinical discharge planner (where relevant).
- Includes relevant health care needs in the development of the community supervision strategy.
- Participates in pre-release conferences when the offender is subject to a condition (e.g., condition to take a medication).
- Institutional nurse, in preparation for offender discharge is responsible for the following:
- Consults with the clinical discharge planner as required to arrange for follow-up appointments for community health care services.
Appendix I: References and Supplementary Information for Specific Populations of Offenders
Women Offenders
ProfileEndnote cclviii
- As of 2015-16, there were a total of 1,275 women offenders in CSC, representing 6% of the total number of federal offenders (n=22,969),Footnote 164 including:
- 691 women offenders in custody, representing 5% of the total in custody population (n=14,646).
- 584 women offenders under community supervision, representing 7% of the total community population (n=8,323).
Prevalent Health NeedsEndnote cclix
- According to several research reports that examined offender health needs,Footnote 165 the most prevalent health conditions for women included: some infectious diseases (e.g., HIV/AIDS, HCV), chronic health conditions (e.g., back pain), and various mental health disorders (e.g., antisocial personality disorder, major depressive episode).
Health-Related Policies and Guidelines
- Commissioner's Directive (CD) 800 Health Services: "are sensitive to the needs of Aboriginal and women offenders, and offenders with special needs."Endnote cclx
- Commissioner's Directive (CD) 578 Intensive Intervention Strategy in Women Offender Institutions/Units.Endnote cclxi
Health-Related Strategies and InitiativesEndnote cclxii
- CSC developed the Infectious Disease Strategy for Women Offenders (2008-2013) as a framework for the prevention, care, and treatment of infectious diseases in order to support women offenders affected by infectious diseases.Endnote cclxiii The Strategy was intended "to prevent the transmission and acquisition of infectious diseases among women offenders during incarceration and to provide appropriate care, treatment and support to those who are infected."Endnote cclxiv
- The Intensive Intervention Strategy for Women Offenders was initiated in 1999Endnote cclxv and was developed to better respond to women offenders experiencing self-injurious behaviour, adjustment problems, difficulties with daily living, and/or other emotional or behavioural problems. As part of the Strategy, women offenders are offered Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT), which is a systematic and comprehensive psychotherapeutic intervention approach that involves learning and developing strategies to help regulate problematic emotions and behaviours.Endnote cclxvi
- The Peer Mentorship program does not provide therapeutic counselling; rather, it is meant to provide confidential support, and connect offenders to resources and services within and outside the institution. The program provides an opportunity for increased problem solving for individuals and contributes to the personal development and employability of offenders who are trained as Peer Mentors. Implementation of Peer Mentorship is scheduled for 2016-17.Endnote cclxvii
Overall Perceptions of Health Services for Women OffendersFootnote 166
- Many staff member respondents agreed that health services were meeting the needs of Women offenders:
- Institutional Health Services:
- Health services staff: 71%, n=36
- General staff: 83%, n=40
- Community Mental Health Services:
- Health services staff: 72%, n=38
- General staff: 57%, n=52
- Staff reported challenges:
- A few CSC staff members (n=17) indicated that there were insufficient resources for community mental health, including access to CSC mental health services or other mental health services in the community.
Indigenous Offenders
ProfileEndnote cclxviii
- As of 2015-16, there were a total of 5,223 Indigenous offenders in CSC, representing 23% of the total number of federal offenders (n=22,969),Footnote 167 including:
- 3,778 Indigenous offenders in custody, representing 26% of the total in custody population (n=14,646)
- 1,445 Indigenous offenders under community supervision, representing 17% of the total community population (n=8,323)
- As of 2014-15, there were 3,600 Indigenous offenders in custody and 1,356 in the community, representing approximately 22% of CSC's population.Endnote cclxix
Prevalent Health Needs
- According to several research reports examining offender health needs,Footnote 168 Indigenous offenders were more likely than non-Indigenous offenders to have health needs in some areas of mental health (e.g., antisocial personality disorder) and chronic health conditions (e.g., central nervous system conditions, diabetes) and infectious diseases (e.g., HCV, HIV/AIDS).Endnote cclxx
Health-Related Policies and Guidelines
- According to Commissioner's Directive (CD) 702: Aboriginal Offenders, the Institutional Head is responsible for ensuring that offenders are provided with services from an Elder/Spiritual Advisor.Endnote cclxxi
- According to the Integrated Mental Health Guidelines, mental health care professionals must "document that Aboriginal Social history has been considered in arriving at a conclusion and recommendations, and integrate a discussion of relevant aspects of this history into assessment reports."Endnote cclxxii
Health-Related Strategies and InitiativesEndnote cclxxiii
- The Aboriginal Health Strategy (2009-2012) offered a strategic framework for CSC to improve culturally-appropriate health services for Indigenous offenders, based on the continuum of care (i.e., through intake, incarceration, pre-release, and community corrections) and the Medicine Wheel. The Strategy had three primary goals:Endnote cclxxiv
- Increase the focus on the health needs of Aboriginal offenders
- Building capacity for culturally-safe health servicesFootnote 169
- Enhancing collaboration within and outside of CSCFootnote 170
- An Indigenous culture component was recently added to the Fundamentals of Mental Health Training. The training provides modules that educate on traditional values for Indigenous health, Indigenous social history, symptoms of mental disorder, and resources for working with Indigenous offenders. The modules also focus on applying Gladue principles through case studies.
- As of 2016, the Director General, Aboriginal Initiatives sits on the National Complex Mental Health Committee to provide input into appropriate care for Indigenous Offenders with complex mental health needs.Endnote cclxxv
Overall Perceptions of Health Services for Indigenous OffendersFootnote 171
- Many staff member respondents agreed that health services were meeting the needs of Indigenous offenders in the institution, but fewer agreed that we were meeting their needs in the community:
- Institutional Health Services:
- Health services staff: 65%, n=78
- General staff: 72%, n=69
- Staff reported challenges:
- Need to address Indigenous health needs in culturally responsive ways (n=12)
- Insufficient resources (n=6)
- Community Mental Health Services:
- Health services staff: 49%, n=34
- General staff: 35%, n=44
- Staff reported challenges:
- Insufficient resources, including difficulties accessing mental health services in remote locations or on reserve, or insufficient Indigenous staff members or Elders (n=37)
- Communication or cultural barriers (n=9)
- Elder Services:
- Some health services staff respondents reported consulting with Elders regarding Indigenous offenders for:
- Mental health services (51%, n=66)
- Clinical health services (28%, n=35)
- Public health services (9%, n=11)
- Health services staff reported that they consulted an Elder to discuss:
- Mental health treatment plans or interventions (n=22)
- Understanding of offenders' cultural beliefs and languages (n=22)
- Use of culturally sensitive approaches in clinical health care (n=15)
- Health services staff suggested that Elders should be more involved in:
- Treatments, services, or interventions for offenders (n=18)
- Communication and information sharing with health services (n=12)
- Some health services staff respondents reported consulting with Elders regarding Indigenous offenders for:
- Offender Perceptions:
- Among Indigenous offenders interviewed (n=51):
- A few (n=3), reported having an Elder present while receiving health care services. Some (n=17) said that it would have been beneficial (e.g., to help navigate the health system, to provide information on traditional health alternatives).
- Among Indigenous offenders interviewed (n=51):
Other Visible Minority Offenders
ProfileEndnote cclxxvi
- The following table shows the ethnic groupings of all CSC offenders at the end 2015-16.Footnote 172 The most common other visible minorities (i.e., non-Indigenous offenders) were Black, Asian, and Other offenders.
Ethnic Grouping | Total (%) |
---|---|
Indigenous | 5,223 (23%) |
Asian | 1,256 (5%) |
Black | 1,768 (8%) |
Caucasian | 13,521 (59%) |
Hispanic | 237 (1%) |
Other | 964 (4%) |
Overall Perceptions of Health Services for Other Visible Minority OffendersFootnote 173
- Many staff member respondents agreed that health services were meeting the needs of other visible minority offenders in the institution, but fewer agreed that we were meeting their needs in the community.
- Institutional Health Services:
- Health services staff: 66%, n=74
- General staff: 75%, n=71
- Staff reported challenges:
- Communication and cultural barriers (n=7).
- Community Mental Health Services:
- Health services staff: 52%, n=34
- General staff: 29%, n=30
- Staff reported challenges, primarily related to community mental health services:
- Insufficient resources to meet the needs of visible minority populations (e.g., limited services, lack of information resources; n=18).
- Language and/or cultural barriers (n=9).
Older Offenders
ProfileEndnote cclxxvii
- As people age, the risk of ill health or disability increases, as does the demand for health care.Endnote cclxxviii Today, aging Canadians face chronic, mental health, and neurological conditions.Endnote cclxxix
- As of 2015-16, there were a total of 6,675 older offenders in CSC, representing 29% of the total number of federal offenders (n=22,969),Footnote 174 including:
- 3,544 older offenders in custody, representing 24% of the total in custody population (n=14,646)
- 3,131 older offenders under community supervision, representing 38% of the total community population (n=8,323).
Prevalent Health Needs
- According to several research reports that examined offender health needs,Footnote 175 older offenders had a higher prevalence than offenders under the age of 50 in some areas, such as chronic health conditions (e.g., cardiovascular system issues, diabetes) and infectious diseases (e.g., HIV/AIDS, HCV).Endnote cclxxx
Health-Related Policies and GuidelinesEndnote cclxxxi
- According to the National Essential Health Services Framework core essential health services include physical health, mental health, public health, and dental services. Although there are some exceptions, many items relevant to older offenders and/or offenders with physical disabilities (e.g., mobility devices) are provided under special authorization.Endnote cclxxxii
- According to the Integrated Mental Health Guidelines, offenders may be referred for admission to RTC if they experience cognitive and/or physical disabilities (e.g., dementia) that are associated with aging and require 24-hour nursing and other clinical care.Endnote cclxxxiii
- According to the Federal Correctional Facilities Accommodation Guidelines, "all areas within institutions must be accessible to the disabled, including staff, visitor and inmate activity areas". Although some spaces are not required to be accessible due to the nature of the activities (e.g., control posts, mechanical spaces), a portion of spaces are required to be accessible (i.e., a maximum of 2% of cells/bedrooms and support space within housing units).Endnote cclxxxiv Although these guidelines do not directly address challenges for older offenders, they provide options to address issues of accessibility and mobility, which commonly affect older offenders.
- There are a total of 15,364 regular population (rated-capacity) cells within CSC institutions. Of those, CSC provides 428 barrier-free cells, of which 37 are transitional (i.e., health care cells, segregation cells). As such, 391 permanent barrier-free cells represent 2.5% of all accessible spaces across CSC, which is above the 2% requirement in the Federal Correctional Facilities Accommodation Guidelines for CSC as a whole. However, some individual institutions were above the 2% level of accessible cells, whereas others were below.
- Barrier-free cells are provided in maximum, medium, and minimum security institutions, women's institutions, multi-level institutions, healing lodgesFootnote 176 as well as in its RTCs. These cells are distributed in each of the five Regions as follows:
- Atlantic: 43
- Ontario: 111
- Quebec: 75
- Prairies: 115
- Pacific: 84
Health-Related Strategies and InitiativesEndnote cclxxxv
- CSC Health Services is currently developing a comprehensive Chronic Disease Management Strategy.
- The Chronic Disease Management Strategy includes seven key health priorities: HIV, HCV, chronic pain, cardiovascular disease, respiratory disease, and the use of antibiotics.
- Although the Chronic Disease Management Strategy is not specifically designated for older offenders, many of the health issues prioritized in the strategy include health issues prevalent among older offender populations.
- Health Services conducts screening for "fall risk" as part of the Intake Health Status Assessment for offenders aged 65 and olderFootnote 177 and/or those with self-care needs (as of August 2015, the age requirement to conduct an assessment for incarcerated offenders has changed from 50 years or older to 65 years or older).Endnote cclxxxvi The assessment examines factors related to activities of daily living.Endnote cclxxxvii, Footnote 178
- The Pacific Region has created a psycho-geriatric unit at the RTC, called Echo, with a Peer Assisted Living (PAL) Caregiver program.Endnote cclxxxviii
- PAL Caregivers are offenders who work in cooperation with staff to assist a peer who has a physical or cognitive disability, in activities of daily living (e.g., help with eating, bathing, dressing, toileting, maintenance of the living environment and mobility).
- Training is provided and offenders applying to the program should be actively engaged in their correctional plan and demonstrate positive working relationships with their case management team.
Overall Perceptions of Health Services for Older OffendersFootnote 179
- Some staff agreed that health services were meeting the health-related needs of older offenders in the institution and in the community.
- Institutional Health Services:
- Health services staff: 41%, n=52
- General staff: 59%, n=61
- Staff reported challenges:
- Insufficient resources, services and specialized service providers (e.g., personal care, geriatric specialists, high needs/multiple needs offenders; n=36)
- Challenges accommodating the needs of older offenders within the existing infrastructure (e.g., provide specialized unit or range for offenders with mobility or age related issues; n=34)
- Community Mental Health Services:
- Health services staff: 46%, n=34
- General staff: 34%, n=41
- Staff reported challenges:
- Insufficient resources, such as palliative care or mental health professionals (n=27)
- Difficulties finding accommodations (e.g., community care facilities willing to accept them, CCCs/CRFs not equipped for their needs; n=20)
- Twenty-nine percent (29%, n=42) of offenders interviewed reported being over the age of fifty; of these, 57% (n=24) reported having age-related health care needs. They reported having age-related needs such as:
- Joint or muscle problems (n=12),
- Cardiovascular conditions (n=5), or
- Other age-related chronic conditions (e.g., diabetes, menopause, etc; n=12).
- Older offenders also reported experiencing challenges with the physical layout of the institution (55%, n=12), accessing specialized health care equipment (47%, n=9), and performing daily activities (33%, n=7).
- Offenders interviewed made the following suggestions to address age-related challenges: Offer specialized services (e.g., hearing specialist, pain clinics; n=12);
- Provide access to specialized products and equipment (e.g., eyeglasses, cane; n=11); and,
- Accommodate older offenders through infrastructure changes (e.g., improve wheelchair accessibility; n=10).
References
- Endnote i
-
Corrections and Conditional Release Act, SC 1992, c 20.
- Endnote ii
-
Public Safety Canada. (2015). Corrections and conditional release statistical overview. Ottawa, ON: p. 48.
- Endnote iii
-
Infonet. (2016). Health services. Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/Sectors/HealthServices/pages/home.aspx.
- Endnote iv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Reports on plans and priorities 2016-17. Ottawa, ON: p. 7-12.
- Endnote v
-
Beaudette, J., Power, J., & Stewart, L. (2015). National prevalence of mental disorders among incoming federally-sentenced men offenders (R-357). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Estimates of chronic disease prevalence among CSC inmates. Ottawa, ON: Health Services.; Derkzen, D., Booth, L., McConnell, A., & Taylor, K. (2012). Mental health needs of federal women offenders (R-267). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service of Canada.; Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of incoming federally-sentenced women offenders (R-332). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Stewart et al. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of newly admitted federally-sentenced men offenders (R-314). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote vi
-
Massoglia, M. (2008). Incarceration as exposure: The prison, infectious disease, and other stress-related illnesses. Journal of Health and Social Behaviour 49(1), 56-71.; Stewart, L., Sapers, J., Nolan, A., & Power, J. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of newly admitted federally-sentenced men offenders (R-314). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Thompson, B., & Finch, R. (2005). Hepatitis C virus infection. Clinical Microbiology and Infection 11(2), 87.
- Endnote vii
-
Awofeso, N. (2010). Prisons as social determinants of hepatitis C virus and tuberculosis infections. Public Health Reports 125, 25-33.; Massoglia, M. (2008). Incarceration as exposure: The prison, infectious disease, and other stress-related illnesses. Journal of Health and Social Behaviour 49(1), 56-71.; Williams, N. (2007). Prison health and the health of the public: Ties that bind. Journal of Correctional Health Care 13(2), 80-92.
- Endnote viii
-
Awofeso, N. (2010). Prisons as social determinants of hepatitis C virus and tuberculosis infections. Public Health Reports 125, 25-33.; Massoglia, M. (2008). Incarceration as exposure: The prison, infectious disease, and other stress-related illnesses. Journal of Health and Social Behaviour 49(1), 56-71.; Williams, N. (2007). Prison health and the health of the public: Ties that bind. Journal of Correctional Health Care 13(2), 80-92.
- Endnote ix
-
Public Safety Canada. (2015). Corrections and conditional release statistical overview. Ottawa, ON: p. 48.
- Endnote x
-
Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of incoming federally-sentenced women offenders (R-332). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Stewart, L., et al. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of newly admitted federally-sentenced men offenders (R-314). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote xi
-
Sifunda, S., et al. (2008). The effectiveness of a peer-led HIV/AIDS and STI health education intervention for prison inmates in South Africa. Health Education & Behavior 35(4), 494-508.
- Endnote xii
-
Dumont, D., et al. (2012). Public health and the epidemic of incarceration. Annual Review of Public Health 33, 325-329.
- Endnote xiii
-
Corrections and Conditional Release Act, SC 1992, c 20. Retrieved from http://canlii.ca/t/52129.
- Endnote xiv
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2015, July 23). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xv
-
Hayton, P. (2007). Protecting and promoting health in prisons: A settings approach. In L. Moller, et al. (Eds.), Health in prisons: A WHO guide to the essentials of prison health (pp. 15-20). Copenhagen, DK: WHO Publications.
- Endnote xvi
-
Stewart, L., Sapers, J., Nolan, A., & Power, J. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of newly admitted federally-sentenced men offenders (R-314). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote xvii
-
Awofeso, N. (2010). Prisons as social determinants of hepatitis C virus and tuberculosis infections. Public Health Reports, 125, 25-33.; Massoglia, M. (2008). Incarceration as exposure: The prison, infectious disease, and other stress-related illnesses. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 49(1), 56-71.; Tarbuck, A. (2001). Health of elderly inmates. Age and Ageing, 30(5), 369-370.
- Endnote xviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Commissioner's Directive 800: Health services. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xix
-
Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of incoming federally-sentenced women offenders (R-332). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Stewart et al. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of newly admitted federally-sentenced men offenders (R-314). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote xx
-
Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of incoming federally-sentenced women offender (R-332). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote xxi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Estimates of chronic disease prevalence among CSC inmates. Ottawa, ON: Health Services.
- Endnote xxii
-
Beaudette, J., & Stewart, L. (2014). Research in brief: Older offenders in the custody of the Correctional Service of Canada (RS 14-21). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote xxiii
-
Stewart, L., Sapers, J., Nolan, A., & Power, J. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of newly admitted federally-sentenced men offenders (R-314). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote xxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Public health quarterly report FY 2013-2014. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xxv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Estimates of chronic disease prevalence among CSC inmates. Ottawa, ON: Health Services.
- Endnote xxvi
-
Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of incoming federally-sentenced women offenders (R-332). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Stewart et al. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of newly admitted federally-sentenced men offenders (R-314). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service of Canada.
- Endnote xxvii
-
Public Health Agency of Caanda. (2013). Tuberculosis in Canada 2013 – Pre-release. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xxviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Estimates of chronic disease prevalence among CSC inmates. Ottawa, ON: Health Services.
- Endnote xxix
-
Statistics Canada. (2013, September 18). Health at a glance: Mental and substance use disorders in Canada. Retrieved from http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/82-624-x/2013001/article/11855-eng.htm.
- Endnote xxx
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Mental Health Branch performance measurement report: Year-end results 2013-14. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xxxi
-
Beaudette, J., Power, J., & Stewart, L. (2015). National prevalence of mental disorders among incoming federally-sentenced men offenders (R-357). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Derkzen, D., Booth, L., McConnell, A., & Taylor, K. (2012). Mental health needs of federal women offenders (R-267). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service of Canada.
- Endnote xxxii
-
American Psychological Association. (2012). DSM-IV and DSM-5 criteria for the personality disorders. Washington, D.C.
- Endnote xxxiii
-
All statistics on self-injurious behaviour were obtained from Power, J., Gordon, A., Sapers, J., & Beaudette, J. (2012). A replication study of self-injury incidents in CSC institutions over a thirty-month period (R-293). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote xxxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). 2015-16 Report on plans and priorities. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xxxv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Health Services sector priorities for 2013-2015. Retrieved from http://infonet/Sectors/HealthServices?lang=en.
- Endnote xxxvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Health Services sector priorities for 2013-2015. Retrieved from http://infonet/Sectors/HealthServices?lang=en.
- Endnote xxxvii
-
Government of Canada. (2014). Mental health action plan for federal offenders. Ottawa, ON. Retrieved from http://publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/cntrng-crm/crrctns/mntl-hlth-ctn-pln-eng.aspx.
- Endnote xxxviii
-
Government of Canada. (2015). Making real change happen: Speech from the Throne to open the first session of the forty-second Parliament of Canada. Retrieved from http://www.speech.gc.ca/en/content/making-real-change-happen.
- Endnote xxxix
-
Government of Canada. (2015). Minister of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness mandate letter. Retrieved from http://pm.gc.ca/eng/minister-public-safety-and-emergency-preparedness-mandate-letter.
- Endnote xl
-
Canada Health Act, RSC 1985, c C-6. Retrieved from http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/c-6/page-1.html.; The Constitution Act, 1982, Schedule B to the Canada Act 1982 (UK), 1982, c 11. Retrieved from http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/Const/page-15.html#h-38. For further information, see Chenier, N. M. (2014). Federal responsibility for the health care of specific groups (PRB 04-52E). Ottawa, ON: Library of Parliament; Tiedemann, M. (2008). The federal role in health and health care (2008-58-E). Ottawa, ON: Parliament of Canada.
- Endnote xli
-
Corrections and Conditional Release Act, SC 1992, c 20. Retrieved from http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-44.6/page-1.html.
- Endnote xlii
-
Thomas, J. (2010). Report on assessment framework for alternative service delivery. Ottawa, ON.; Thomas, J. (2011). Implementing the CSC report on an assessment framework for alternative service delivery: Report for CSC's Executive Committee meeting on October 5, 2011. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xliii
-
Hall, N., & Weaver, C. (2008). A framework for diversion of persons with a mental disorder in BC. Vancouver, BC: Canadian Mental Health Association.
- Endnote xliv
-
Hall, N., & Weaver, C. (2008). A framework for diversion of persons with a mental disorder in BC. Vancouver, BC: Canadian Mental Health Association.; Heilbrun et al. (2012). Community-based alternatives for justice-involved individuals with severe mental illness: Review of the relevant research. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 39(4), 351-419.; Livingston, J., Weaver, C., Hall, N., & Verdun-Jones, S. (2008). Criminal justice diversion for persons with mental disorders: A review of best practices. Vancouver, BC: Canadian Mental Health Association.; Munetz, M., & Griffin, P. (2006). Use of the sequential intercept model as an approach to decriminalization of people with serious mental illness. Psychiatric Services, 57(4), 544-549.
- Endnote xlv
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2013). Community mental health service delivery guidelines. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xlvi
-
Statistics Canada. (2007). Canadian community health survey: Mental health and well-being. Retrieved from http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/82-617-x/index-eng.htm.
- Endnote xlvii
-
Friedli, L., & Parsonage, M. (2007). Mental health promotion: Building an economic case. Belfast, IE: Northern Ireland Association for Mental Health.; Hill, J. (2003). Early identification of individuals at risk for antisocial personality disorder. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 182(44), s11-s14.
- Endnote xlviii
-
Aos, S., Miller, M., & Drake, E. (2006). Evidence-based public policy options to reduce future prison construction, criminal justice costs, and crime rates. Olympia, WA: Washing State Institute for Public Policy.
- Endnote xlix
-
National Crime Prevention Centre. (2013). The Stop Now and Plan Program – SNAP: Crime prevention in action. Ottawa, ON: Public Safety Canada.
- Endnote l
-
Farrington, D., & Koegl, C. (2014).The monetary benefits and costs of the Stop Now and Plan Program for boys aged 6-11, based on the prevention of later offending. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 31(2), 263-287.
- Endnote li
-
Heilbrun et al. (2012). Community-based alternatives for justice-involved individuals with severe mental illness: Review of the relevant research. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 39(4), 351-419.; Sarteschi, C., Vaughn, M., & Kim, K. (2011). Assessing the effectiveness of mental health courts: A quantitative review. Journal of Criminal Justice, 39(1), 12-20.
- Endnote lii
-
Cowell, A., Broner, N., & Dupont, R. (2004). The cost effectiveness of criminal justice diversion programs for people with serious mental illness co-occurring with substance abuse: Four case studies. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 20(3), 292-315
- Endnote liii
-
Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, & Canadian Council on Social Development. (2011). Turning the key: Assessing housing and related supports for persons living with mental health problems and illness. Calgary, AB: Mental Health Commission of Canada.; Heilbrun et al. (2012). Community-based alternatives for justice-involved individuals with severe mental illness: Review of the relevant research. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 39(4), 351-419.; Lindberg, A. (2009). Examining the program costs and outcomes of San Francisco's Behavioral Health Court: Predicting success. San Francisco, CA: Office of Collaborative Justice Programs, Superior Court of California, San Francisco County.; Ridgely et al. (2007). Justice, treatment and cost: An evaluation of the fiscal impact of Allegheny Country Mental Health Court. Santa Monica, CA: RAND.
- Endnote liv
-
Laliberté, D., Rosario, G., Léonard, L., Smith-Moncrieffe, D., & Warner, A. (2014). Results of crime prevention programs for 12 to 17 year olds. Ottawa, ON: National Crime Prevention Centre, Public Safety Canada.
- Endnote lv
-
Heilbrun et al. (2012). Community-based alternatives for justice-involved individuals with severe mental illness: Review of the relevant research. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 39(4), 351-419.
- Endnote lvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Nursing intake assessment and medication reconciliation analysis 2013-2014. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Mental Health Branch performance measurement report: Year end results 2013-14. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lviii
-
Accreditation Canada. (2014). Accreditation Report: Correctional Services Canada, Health Services. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lix
-
Wilton, G., Stewart, L., & Power, J. (2014). Emerging research results – Agreement among three mental health screening measures (B58). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote lx
-
Correctional Service Canada (2014). Health care requirements on reception and transfer. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lxi
-
Correctional Service Canada (2014). Computerized Mental Health Intake Screening System version 2.2 – National guidelines. Ottawa, ON.; Correctional Service Canada (2014). Mental health screening. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lxii
-
Wilton et al. (2014). Emerging research results – Agreement among three mental health screening measures (B58). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote lxiii
-
Wilton et al. (2014). Emerging research results – Agreement among three mental health screening measures (B58). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote lxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Mental Health Branch performance measurement report: Year end results 2014-15. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lxv
-
Wilton et al. (2014). Emerging research results – Agreement among three mental health screening measures (B58). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote lxvi
-
Wilton et al. (2014). Emerging research results – Agreement among three mental health screening measures (B58). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote lxvii
-
Corrections and Conditional Release Act, SC 1992, c 20.
- Endnote lxviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lxix
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON: p. 7.
- Endnote lxx
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON: p. 2.
- Endnote lxxi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON: Annex A.
- Endnote lxxii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Health services sector 2012-2013 performance measurement report. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lxxiii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Unpublished Health Services surveillance data.
- Endnote lxxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Unpublished Health Services surveillance data.
- Endnote lxxv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Unpublished Health Services surveillance data.
- Endnote lxxvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Unpublished Health Services surveillance data.
- Endnote lxxvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Health services sector 2012-2013 performance measurement report. Ottawa, ON: p. 14.
- Endnote lxxviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lxxix
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Commissioner's Directive 800: Health services. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lxxx
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON: p. 1.
- Endnote lxxxi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lxxxii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2012). Towards a continuum of care. Retrieved from http://www.csc-scc.gc.ca/002/006/002006-2000-eng.shtml.
- Endnote lxxxiii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Mental health branch performance measurement report: Year end results 2014-15. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lxxxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Mental health branch performance measurement report: Year end results 2014-15. Ottawa, ON: p. 13.
- Endnote lxxxv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Mental health branch performance measurement report: Year end results 2014-15. Ottawa, ON: p. 16.
- Endnote lxxxvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lxxxvii
-
COACH. (2015). 2015 Canadian telehealth report. Toronto, ON.
- Endnote lxxxviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Health Services Ontario Telemedicine Network. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote lxxxix
-
Accreditation Canada. (2014). Accreditation report: Correctional Service Canada, Health Services. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xc
-
Glauser, W., Nolan, M., & Remfry, A. (2015). Telemedicine on the rise across Canada. Retrieved from http://healthydebate.ca/2015/06/topic/telemedicine-across-canada.
- Endnote xci
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Health Services Ontario Telemedicine Network. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xcii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Health Services: Expanding the use of telemedicine. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xciii
-
Schaenman, P., et al. (2013). Opportunities for cost savings in corrections without sacrificing service quality: Inmate health care. Washington, D.C.: p. 20.
- Endnote xciv
-
PEW Charitable Trusts and MacArthur Foundation. (2014). State prison health care spending: An examination. Retrieved from http://www.pewtrusts.org/mwg-internal/de5fs23hu73ds/progress?id=90xXyrs8KPMaqrCmWFgw_Lg5J4mOsLwoxa-1IUpxoP8; Reno, J., et al. (1999). Telemedicine can reduce correctional health care costs: An evaluation of a prison telemedicine network. Washington, D.C.
- Endnote xcv
-
Reno, J., et al. (1999). Telemedicine can reduce correctional health care costs: An evaluation of a prison telemedicine network. Washington, D.C.
- Endnote xcvi
-
Ollove, M. (2016). State prisons turn to telemedicine to improve health and save money. Retrieved from http://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/blogs/stateline/2016/01/21/state-prisons-turn-to-telemedicine-to-improve.
- Endnote xcvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote xcviii
-
Barua, B. (2015). Waiting your turn: Wait times for health care in Canada. Vancouver, BC: The Fraser Institute.
- Endnote xcix
-
Health Canada. (2012). First Minister's meeting on the future of health care. Retrieved from http://healthycanadians.gc.ca/health-system-systeme-sante/services/quality-qualite/wait-attente/meeting-rencontre-eng.php.
- Endnote c
-
COACH. (2013) 2013 Canadian telehealth report. Toronto, ON.
- Endnote ci
-
COACH. (2013) 2013 Canadian telehealth report. Toronto, ON.
- Endnote cii
-
COACH. (2013) 2013 Canadian telehealth report. Toronto, ON.
- Endnote ciii
-
Glauser, W., Nolan, M., & Remfry, A. (2015). Telemedicine on the rise across Canada. Retrieved from http://healthydebate.ca/2015/06/topic/telemedicine-across-canada.
- Endnote civ
-
Glauser, W., Nolan, M., & Remfry, A. (2015). Telemedicine on the rise across Canada. Retrieved from http://healthydebate.ca/2015/06/topic/telemedicine-across-canada.
- Endnote cv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Commissioner's Directive 710-2-3: Inmate transfer process. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Guidelines for sharing personal health information. Ottawa, ON: p. 3.
- Endnote cvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Guidelines for sharing personal health information. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Guidelines for sharing personal health information. Ottawa, ON: p. 4.
- Endnote cix
-
Canada Health Infoway. (2013). The emerging benefits of electronic medical record use in community-based care. Toronto, ON.
- Endnote cx
-
Health Infoway. (2013). The emerging benefits of electronic medical record use in community-based care. Toronto, ON; Knight, D. (2009). Electronic medical records: Moving jails forward. Retrieved from http://www.corrections.com/news/article/22296-electronic-medical-records-moving-jails-forward.
- Endnote cxi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Guidelines for sharing personal health information. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Guidelines for sharing personal health information. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxiii
-
Correctional Service Canada (2012). Health services sector 2011-2012 performance measurement report. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Health promotion. Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/Sectors/HealthServices/PublicHealth/Pages/HealthPromotion.aspx.
- Endnote cxv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Health services sector 2012-2013 performance measurement report. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Health promotion. Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/Sectors/HealthServices/PublicHealth/Pages/HealthPromotion.aspx.
- Endnote cxvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2012). Inmate suicide awareness and prevention workshop: Participant's manual. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Health promotion. Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/Sectors/HealthServices/PublicHealth/Pages/HealthPromotion.aspx.
- Endnote cxix
-
Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (unpublished document, under review). Correctional health promotion and health education initiatives: A review of the literature. Correctional Service of Canada. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxx
-
Correctional Service Canada (2014). Commissioner's directive 705: Intake assessment process and correctional plan framework. Ottawa, ON: p.3.
- Endnote cxxi
-
Correctional Service Canada (2012). Health services sector 2012-2013 performance measurement report. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Performance measurement public health branch report 2013-2014. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxiii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Departmental performance report. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Public health quarterly report – FY 2014-2015. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Performance measurement public health branch report 2013-2014. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Performance measurement public health branch report 2013-2014. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Performance measurement public health branch report 2013-2014. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxviii
-
Correctional Service Canada (2013). Commissioner's directive 843: Management of inmate self-injurious and suicidal behaviour. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxix
-
Correctional Service of Canada (2012). Health services sector 2010-2011 performance measurement report. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxx
-
Zakaria, D., Thompson, J., & Borgatta, F. (2010). The relationship between knowledge of HIV and HCV, health education, and risk and harm-reducing behaviours among Canadian federal inmates (R-195). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote cxxxi
-
Zakaria, D., Thompson, J., & Borgatta, F. (2010). The relationship between knowledge of HIV and HCV, health education, and risk and harm-reducing behaviours among Canadian federal inmates (R-195). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote cxxxii
-
Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (unpublished document, under review). Correctional health promotion and health education initiatives: A review of the literature. Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote cxxxiii
-
Health Canada and the Public Health Agency of Canada. (2014). Evaluation of the federal initiative to address HIV/AIDS in Canada 2008-09 to 2012-13. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxxiv
-
EI Saadany, S., et al. (2005). Economic burden of hepatitis C in Canada and the potential impact of prevention: Results from a disease model. The European Journal of Health Economics, 6(2), 159-165.
- Endnote cxxxv
-
Health Canada and the Public Health Agency of Canada. (2014). Evaluation of the federal initiative to address HIV/AIDS in Canada 2008-09 to 2012-13. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxxvi
-
Health Canada and the Public Health Agency of Canada. (2014). Evaluation of the federal initiative to address HIV/AIDS in Canada 2008-09 to 2012-13. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxxxvii
-
Cohen, D., Wu, S., & Farley, T. (2004). Comparing the cost-effectiveness of HIV prevention interventions. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 37(3), 1404-1414.
- Endnote cxxxviii
-
Cohen, D., Wu, S., & Farley, T. (2004). Comparing the cost-effectiveness of HIV prevention interventions. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 37(3), 1404-1414.
- Endnote cxxxix
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Sexually transmitted infection guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.65; Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Commissioner's directive 800: Health Services. Ottawa, ON: p.3.
- Endnote cxl
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Report on the national review of CSC's opiate substitution therapy program. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxli
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Commissioner's directive 800: Health services. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxlii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Guidelines 800-6: Bleach distribution. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxliii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Compliance and operational risk report: Fall 2015 review. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxliv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Compliance and operational risk report: Fall 2015 review. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxlv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxlvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Regional treatment centre standardized processes. Ottawa, ON: p. 1.
- Endnote cxlvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2012). Towards a continuum of care: Correctional Service Canada mental health strategy. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxlviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 12.
- Endnote cxlix
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 30.
- Endnote cl
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Mental health branch performance measurement report: Year end results 2014-15. Ottawa, ON: p. 19.
- Endnote cli
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 2.
- Endnote clii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2012). Towards a continuum of care: Correctional Service Canada mental health strategy. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cliii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 22-23.
- Endnote cliv
-
Infonet. (2016). Suicide and self-injury prevention. Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/Sectors/HealthServices/MentalHealth/Pages/SuicideandSIB.aspx.
- Endnote clv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (n.d.). Regional complex mental health committees: Terms of reference. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote clvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Unpublished Health Services data.
- Endnote clvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Regional complex mental health committees: Terms of reference. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote clviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning and transfer guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 4.
- Endnote clix
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning and transfer guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 4.
- Endnote clx
-
Correctional Service Canada (2014). Discharge planning and transfer guidelines. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote clxi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning matrix tool. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote clxii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning matrix tool. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote clxiii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2012). Audit of release process. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote clxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Commissioner's directive 712-4: Release process. Ottawa, ON: p. 2.
- Endnote clxv
-
Correctional Service Canada (2015). Commissioner's directive 566-12: Personal property of offenders. Ottawa, ON: p.10.
- Endnote clxvi
-
Inter-provincial Agreement on Eligibility and Portability, as quoted in Correctional Service of Canada. (2011). Offender Identification Cards: Review and Recommendations. Ottawa, ON: p11.
- Endnote clxvii
-
Correctional Service Canada (2014). Discharge Planning and Transfer Guidelines. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote clxviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Commissioner's directive 860: Offender's money. Ottawa, ON: p. 3.
- Endnote clxix
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning and transfer guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 7.
- Endnote clxx
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning and transfer guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 10.
- Endnote clxxi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning and transfer guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 12-13.
- Endnote clxxii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote clxxiii
-
Correctional Service Canada (2016). National Formulary. Ottawa, ON: p.16. Correctional Service of Canada. (2014). Discharge Planning and Transfer Guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 13. Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Commissioner's directive 712-4: Release process. Ottawa, ON: p. 2 & 5.
- Endnote clxxiv
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote clxxv
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2015). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 36, 39.
- Endnote clxxvi
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.2 & p.42.
- Endnote clxxvii
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.2.; Correctional Service of Canada. (2014). Discharge Planning and Transfer Guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.5.
- Endnote clxxviii
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.36.
- Endnote clxxix
-
MacDonald, S. F., Stewart, L. A., & Feely, S. (2014). Research Report: The Impact of the Community Mental Health Initiative (CMHI) (Report No. R-337).
- Endnote clxxx
-
Allegri et al. (2008). Evaluation Report: Community Mental Health Initiative. Ottawa: ON.
- Endnote clxxxi
-
MacDonald, S. F., Stewart, L. A., & Feely, S. (2014). Research Report: The Impact of the Community Mental Health Initiative (CMHI) (Report No. R-337).
- Endnote clxxxii
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2015). Mental Health Branch Performance Measurement Report. Ottawa, ON: p.61.
- Endnote clxxxiii
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2015). Mental health branch performance measurement report: Year end results 2014-15. Ottawa, ON: p.28.
- Endnote clxxxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning matrix tool. Ottawa, ON:p.2.; Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON:p.3 & 41.
- Endnote clxxxv
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2014). Community Mental Health Service Delivery Guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.18.
- Endnote clxxxvi
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote clxxxvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). New governance structure. Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/Sectors/HealthServices/Pages/governance.aspx.
- Endnote clxxxviii
-
Accreditation Canada. (2014). Correctional Service Canada, Health Services. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote clxxxix
-
Accreditation Canada. (2014). Correctional Service Canada, Health Services. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxc
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Departmental performance report 2013-2014. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxci
-
Myers, R., et al. (2014). Burden of disease and cost of chronic hepatitis C virus infection in Canada. Canadian Journal of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, 28(5), 243-250.
- Endnote cxcii
-
Rein, D. et al., (2015). The cost-effectiveness, health benefits, and financial costs of new antiviral treatments for hepatitis C virus. Clinical Infectious Disease 61(2), 157-68.
- Endnote cxciii
-
Canadian AIDS Treatment Information Exchange (CATIE). (n.d.). Prevention and treatment for hepatitis C virus (HCV). Retrieved from http://www.catie.ca/en/treatmentupdate/treatmentupdate-191/anti-hcv-agents/prevention-and-treatment-hepatitis-c-virus-hcv.
- Endnote cxciv
-
Rein, D. et al., (2015). The cost-effectiveness, health benefits, and financial costs of new antiviral treatments for hepatitis C virus. Clinical Infectious Disease 61(2), 157-68.
- Endnote cxcv
-
Canadian AIDS Treatment Information Exchange (CATIE). (n.d.). About some terms – SVR12 vs. SVR24. Retrieved from http://www.catie.ca/en/treatmentupdate/treatmentupdate-207/hepatitis-c-virus/about-some-terms-svr12-vs-svr24.
- Endnote cxcvi
-
Pearlman, B., & Traub, N. (2011). Sustained virologic response to antiviral therapy for chronic hepatitis C virus infection: A cure and so much more. Journal of Clinical Infectious Diseases 52(7), 889-900.
- Endnote cxcvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Public health quarterly report FY 2013-2014. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxcviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Estimates of chronic disease prevalence among CSC inmates. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cxcix
-
Smith, J., et al. "Treatment outcomes for chronic hepatitis C infection with direct acting antivirals among inmates in federal corrections." Presentation at the Canadian Association for Drugs and Technology in Health (CADTH), National Conference, Ottawa, ON, April 10-12, 2016.
- Endnote cc
-
Myers, R., et al. (2015). An update on the management of chronic hepatitis C: 2015 consensus guidelines from the Canadian Association for the Study of the Liver. Canadian Journal of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, 29(1), 19-34.
- Endnote cci
-
Singal A.G. et al. (2010). A Sustained Viral Response Is Associated With Reduced Liver-Related Morbidity and Mortality in Patients With Hepatitis C Virus. Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology and Hepatology. (8): 280-288. Retrieved on September 21, 2016 from, http://www.cghjournal.org/mwg-internal/de5fs23hu73ds/progress?id=LzDy1jjDi96bBAv9UIcPmTGoZH7EeLartCzJBPL5JMc,&dl
- Endnote ccii
-
Myers RP et al. (2015). An update on the management of chronic hepatitis C: 2015 consensus guidelines from the Canadian Liver Association for the Study of the Liver. Canadian Journal of Gastroenterology and Hepatology. Retrieved on August 30, 2016 from, http://www.liver.ca/files/Professional_Education Partnerships/Information Resources_for_HCP/CASL_Hep_C_Consensus_Guidelines_Update_-_Jan_2015.pdf
- Endnote cciii
-
Public Health Agency of Canada. (2016). Report on Hepatitis B and C in Canada: 2012. Retreived on September 1st, 2016 from, http://healthycanadians.gc.ca/publications/diseases-conditions-maladies-affections/hepatitis-b-c-2012-hepatite-b-c/index-eng.php
- Endnote cciv
-
Tianhua, He. et al. (2015). Prevention of Hepatitis C by Screening and Treatment in United States Prisons. Annals of Internal Medicine. 164(2): 84-92.
- Endnote ccv
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2013). Commissioner's directive 800: Health services. Ottawa, ON: p. 4.
- Endnote ccvi
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2011). Intensive intervention strategy for women offenders. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2008). Correctional Service Canada contract with the Institut Philippe-Pinel de Montréal. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). The impact of the community mental health initiative (CMHI), R-337. Ottawa, ON.; Allegri et al. (2008). Evaluation Report: Community Mental Health Initiative. Ottawa: ON.
- Endnote ccix
-
Canada Health Act, RSC 1985, c C-6.Retrieved from http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-6/page-2.html#docCont.
- Endnote ccx
-
Unless otherwise cited, the self-reported prevalence rates were derived from Stewart, L., et al. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of newly admitted federally-sentenced men offenders (R-314). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote ccxi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Estimates of chronic disease prevalence among CSC inmates. Ottawa, ON: Health Services.
- Endnote ccxii
-
Government of Canada. (2015). Heart disease – heart health. Retrieved from http://healthycanadians.gc.ca/diseases-conditions-maladies-affections/disease-maladie/heart-disease-eng.php.; Munro, M. (2012, January 26). First Nations need obesity prevention socio-economic issues contribute to hypertension, heart disease and diabetes epidemic, report says. Retrieved from http://www.naho.ca/blog/2012/01/26/first-nations-need-obesity-prevention-socio-economic-issues-contribute-to-hypertension-heart-disease-and-diabetes-epidemic-report-says/.
- Endnote ccxiii
-
Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of incoming federally-sentenced women offenders (R-332). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote ccxiv
-
Stewart et al. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of newly admitted federally-sentenced men offenders (R-314). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote ccxv
-
Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of incoming federally-sentenced women offenders (R-332). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote ccxvi
-
Beaudette et al. (2015). National prevalence of mental disorders among incoming federally-sentenced men offenders (R-357). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote ccxvii
-
Beaudette et al. (2015). National prevalence of mental disorders among incoming federally-sentenced men offenders (R-357). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote ccxviii
-
American Psychological Association. (2012). DSM-IV and DSM-5 criteria for the personality disorders. Washington, D.C.
- Endnote ccxix
-
Beaudette et al. (2015). National prevalence of mental disorders among incoming federally-sentenced men offenders (R-357). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Derkzen et al. (2012). Mental health needs of federal women offenders (R-267). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote ccxx
-
Derkzen et al. (2012). Mental health needs of federal women offenders (R-267). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote ccxxi
-
Derkzen et al. (2012). Mental health needs of federal women offenders (R-267). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote ccxxii
-
American Psychological Association. (2012). DSM-IV and DSM-5 criteria for the personality disorders. Washington, D.C.
- Endnote ccxxiii
-
Munetz, M., & Griffin, P. (2006). Use of the sequential intercept model as an approach to decriminalization of people with serious mental illness. Psychiatric Services, 57(4), 544-549.
- Endnote ccxxiv
-
See for example Compton, M., et al. (2011). Use of force preferences and perceived effectiveness of actions among Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) police officers and non-CIT officers in escalating psychiatric crisis involving a subject with Schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Bulletin 37(4), 737-745.; Steadman, H. J., & Naples, M. (2005). Assessing the effectiveness of jail diversion programs for persons with serious mental illness and co-occuring substance abuse disorder. Behavioural Sciences and the Law, 23(2), 163-170.
C) Watson, A., et al. (2010). Outcomes of police contacts with persons with mental illness: The impact of CIT. Administration and Policy in Mental Health 37(4), 302-317.
- Endnote ccxxv
-
Thomas, J. (2010). Report on assessment framework for alternative service delivery. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxxvi
-
Heilbrun et al. (2012). Community-based alternatives for justice-involved individuals with severe mental illness: Review of the relevant research. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 39(4), 351-419.
- Endnote ccxxvii
-
Sarteschi et al. (2011). Assessing the effectiveness of mental health courts: A quantitative review. Journal of Criminal Justice, 39(1), 12-20.; Thomas, J. (2010). Report on assessment framework for alternative service delivery. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxxviii
-
Farrington, D., & Koegl, C. (2014).The monetary benefits and costs of the Stop Now and Plan Program for boys aged 6-11, based on the prevention of later offending. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 31(2), 263-287.
- Endnote ccxxix
-
Griffiths, C., Dandurand, Y., & Murdoch, D. (2007). The social reintegration of offenders and crime prevention. Ottawa, ON: National Crime Prevention Centre, Public Safety Canada.
- Endnote ccxxx
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2012). Mental health strategy for corrections in Canada: A federal-provincial-territorial partnership. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxxxi
-
Livingston et al. (2008). Criminal justice diversion for persons with mental disorders: A review of best practices. Vancouver, BC: Canadian Mental Health Association.
- Endnote ccxxxii
-
Hall, N., & Weaver, C. (2008). A framework for diversion of persons with a mental disorder in BC. Vancouver, BC: Canadian Mental Health Association.
- Endnote ccxxxiii
-
Heilbrun et al. (2012). Community-based alternatives for justice-involved individuals with severe mental illness: Review of the relevant research. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 39(4), 351-419.
- Endnote ccxxxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Health Services Sector 2012-2013 performance measurement report. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxxxv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Health Services Sector 2012-2013 performance measurement report. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxxxvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Health services sector 2012-2013 performance measurement report. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxxxvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Health services sector 2012-2013 performance measurement report. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxxxviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Health services program: Infectious diseases. Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/Regions/Prairie/OurRegion/Institutions/WebSites/EIFW/OurInstitution/Divisions/Interventions/HealthServices/Programs/Pages/InfectiousDiseases.aspx.
- Endnote ccxxxix
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2009). Infectious disease strategy for women inmate 2008-2013. Ottawa, ON
- Endnote ccxl
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2009). Infectious disease strategy for women inmate 2008-2013. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxli
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Health services sector 2012-2013 performance measurement report. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxlii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Health services program: Infectious diseases. Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/Regions/Prairie/OurRegion/Institutions/WebSites/EIFW/OurInstitution/Divisions/Interventions/HealthServices/Programs/Pages/InfectiousDiseases.aspx.
- Endnote ccxliii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2012). Inmate suicide awareness and prevention workshop: Facilitator's manual. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxliv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2012). Inmate suicide awareness and prevention workshop: Facilitator's manual. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxlv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Commissioner's directive 843: Management of inmate self-injurious and suicidal behaviour. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxlvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2012). Inmate suicide awareness and prevention workshop: Facilitator's manual. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote ccxlvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning matrix tool. Ottawa, ON:p.2.; Correctional Service of Canada. (2014). Discharge Planning and Transfer Guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.5,7, 9 & 10.; Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON:p.3 & 41.
- Endnote ccxlviii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning matrix tool. Ottawa, ON:p.2.; Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON:p.37.
- Endnote ccxlix
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON:p.41.
- Endnote ccl
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2014). Discharge Planning and Transfer Guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.5.
- Endnote ccli
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2014). Discharge Planning and Transfer Guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.7.
- Endnote cclii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning matrix tool. Ottawa, ON:p.2.
- Endnote ccliii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning matrix tool. Ottawa, ON:p.2.
- Endnote ccliv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning matrix tool. Ottawa, ON:p.2.
- Endnote cclv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning matrix tool. Ottawa, ON:p.2.
- Endnote cclvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Discharge planning matrix tool. Ottawa, ON:p.2.
- Endnote cclvii
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2014). Discharge Planning and Transfer Guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.9.
- Endnote cclviii
-
Extracted from the data warehouse in October 2016 for all women offenders, data current up to 2016-04-10.
- Endnote cclix
-
Derkzen, et al. (2012). Mental health needs of federal women offenders (R-267). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of incoming federally-sentenced women offenders (R-332). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote cclx
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2013). Commissioner's directive 800: Health services. Ottawa, ON: p. 4.
- Endnote cclxi
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2013). Commissioner's directive 578: Intensive intervention strategy in women's institutions. Ottawa, ON: p. 5.
- Endnote cclxii
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2002). The 2002 mental health strategy for women offenders. Ottawa, ON.; Correctional Service Canada. (2009). Infectious disease strategy for women offenders 2008-2013. Ottawa, ON. Infonet. (2016). Health promotion. Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/Sectors/HealthServices/PublicHealth/Pages/HealthPromotion.aspx.; Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cclxiii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2009). Infectious disease strategy for women offenders 2008-2013. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cclxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2009). Infectious disease strategy for women offenders 2008-2013. Ottawa, ON: p. 8.
- Endnote cclxv
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2002). The 2002 mental health strategy for women offenders. Ottawa, ON: p.5.
- Endnote cclxvi
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2002). The 2002 mental health strategy for women offenders. Ottawa, ON: p.24.
- Endnote cclxvii
-
Hartle, Kelly. (May 16, 2016). Implementation of New Peer Mentorship at Women Offender Institutions. Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote cclxviii
-
Extracted from the data warehouse, October 2016 for all Indigenous offenders, data current up to 2016-04-10.
- Endnote cclxix
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2016). Report on plans and priorities 2016-17. Ottawa, ON..; Public Safety Canada. (2015). Corrections and conditional release statistical overview. Ottawa, ON: p. 64.
- Endnote cclxx
-
Beaudette et al. (2015). National prevalence of mental disorders among incoming federally-sentenced men offenders (R-357). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada..; Derkzen et al. (2012). Mental health needs of federal women offenders (R-267). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of incoming federally-sentenced women offenders (R-332). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Stewart et al. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of newly admitted federally-sentenced men offenders (R-314). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote cclxxi
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2013). Commissioner's directive 702: Aboriginal offenders. Ottawa, ON: p. 3.
- Endnote cclxxii
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.5.
- Endnote cclxxiii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2010). A wellness path to healthy and safe reintegration: Aboriginal health strategy 2009-2012. Ottawa, ON.; Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Guidelines for sharing personal health information. Ottawa, ON.; Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON.; Data extracted from Human Resources Management System (HRMS) in September 2016.
- Endnote cclxxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2010). A wellness path to healthy and safe reintegration: Aboriginal health strategy 2009-2012. Ottawa, ON: p. 6.
- Endnote cclxxv
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p.11.
- Endnote cclxxvi
-
Extracted from the data warehouse, October 2016 for all ethnic groupings, data current up to 2016-04-10.
- Endnote cclxxvii
-
Extracted from the data warehouse October 2016 for all older offenders (i.e., offenders over the age of 50), data current up to 2016-04-10.
- Endnote cclxxviii
-
Canadian Medical Association. (2013). Health and health care for an aging population. Ottawa, ON: p. 2.
- Endnote cclxxix
-
Public Health Agency of Canada. (2014). Report on the state of public health in Canada. Ottawa, ON: p. 3.
- Endnote cclxxx
-
Nolan, A., & Stewart, L. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of incoming federally-sentenced women offenders (R-332). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.; Stewart et al. (2014). Self-reported physical health status of newly admitted federally-sentenced men offenders (R-314). Ottawa, ON: Correctional Service Canada.
- Endnote cclxxxi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Federal correctional facilities accommodation guidelines. Ottawa, ON.; Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON.; Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cclxxxii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2015). National essential health services framework. Ottawa, ON: Appendix A.
- Endnote cclxxxiii
-
Correctional Service of Canada. (2016). Integrated mental health guidelines. Ottawa, ON: p. 28.
- Endnote cclxxxiv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2014). Federal correctional facilities accommodation guidelines. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cclxxxv
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2011). Falls prevention strategy. Ottawa, ON.; Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Adverse events guidelines. Ottawa, ON.; Infonet. (2015). Aging offenders resource kit. Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/SoloSites/ResponsivityPortal/SpecialNeedsResource/Pages/Aging_Offenders.aspx.; Infonet. (2016). Peer Assisted Living Program (PAL). Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/Regions/Pacific/832rhc/service_delivery/Pages/mental_health_services.aspx.
- Endnote cclxxxvi
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2011). Falls prevention strategy. Ottawa, ON: p. 9.
- Endnote cclxxxvii
-
Correctional Service Canada. (2013). Adverse events guidelines. Ottawa, ON.
- Endnote cclxxxviii
-
Infonet. (2016). Peer Assisted Living Program (PAL). Retrieved from http://infonet/eng/Regions/Pacific/832rhc/service_delivery/Pages/mental_health_services.aspx
Footnotes
- Footnote 1
-
A comprehensive list of CDs that involve a health related component can be found in Appendix A
- Footnote 2
-
Transitions in care also include transfers between CSC institutions.
- Footnote 3
-
The federal government has transitioned from using the term Aboriginal to describe First Nations, Inuit and Métis peoples to the term Indigenous. The transition took place during the evaluation. The data collection instruments used the term Aboriginal; however, the evaluation report has replaced this with Indigenous where applicable.
- Footnote 4
-
An iterative and inductive qualitative analysis process identifies emerging themes and meaning from data through a repetitive reflexive process (see Srivastava & Hopwood, 2009 and Patton, 1980).
- Footnote 5
-
The majority of respondents were from the nursing (53.9%, n = 62) and psychology (18.3%, n = 21) groups. The remaining respondents included: social work (7.8%, n =9), clerical (6.1%, n = 7), administrative services (4.3%, n = 5), pharmacy (2.6%, n = 3), welfare programs (2.6%; n = 3), and others.
- Footnote 6
-
The largest percentage of respondents were from the nursing (46.4%, n = 89) and psychology (24.0%, n = 46) classifications. In addition, questionnaires were completed by respondents in the administrative services (8.9%, n =17), clerical (7.3%, n = 14), pharmacy (3.6%, n = 7), social work (3.1%, n =6), engineering and scientific support (2.6%, n = 5), executive and welfare programs (1.6%, n = 3) classifications.
- Footnote 7
-
The majority of respondents worked in the institutions (94.5%, n = 156) while a small proportion were from Regional Headquarters (RHQ; 5.5%, n = 9). The majority of respondents worked in men's institutions (80.1%; n = 125) while a few (19.8%, n = 31) indicated working in women's institutions. The highest proportion of respondents (38.9%, n = 63) were educators followed by correctional officers (21.6%, n = 35) and employees who work in welfare Programs (19.1%, n = 31). A few respondents worked in administrative services (12.3%, n = 20), the executive group (3.7%; n = 6) and other groups (4.3%, n = 7).
- Footnote 8
-
There were mainly two distinct categories of respondents. The largest percentage of respondents was from case management team (57%, n = 165). About half were community parole officers (53%, n = 87), and a small number institutional parole officers (22%, n = 36), parole office supervisors (13%, n = 21). The other category was health services staff (39%, n = 112). Some of the health services staff were institutional nurses (34%, n = 38), community mental health nurses (26%, n = 29), and a small number of clinical social workers (14%; n = 16). There was a remaining small number of uncategorized respondents (5%, n = 14).
- Footnote 9
-
This scale has been adapted from Employment and Social Development Canada.
- Footnote 10
-
Some of the chronic physical health needs can also result in acute episodes (e.g., heart attack).
- Footnote 11
-
These rates were based on self-report of current or past head injury and may therefore include a broad range of injuries. A review of health files found that 2% of offenders had evidence of current or recent brain injury. See Correctional Service Canada. (2015). Estimates of chronic disease prevalence among CSC inmates. Ottawa, ON: Health Services.
- Footnote 12
-
Mental health need is determined by having at least one mental health treatment-oriented service or stay in a treatment centre in the previous six-months.
- Footnote 13
-
This refers to a one-month prevalence rate [the prevalence rate for current disorders (i.e. disorders that were present in the month prior to the study)].
- Footnote 14
-
This refers to a one-year prevalence rate [the sample's continued experiences with an active disorder (i.e. in the year prior to the study)].
- Footnote 15
-
A lifetime prevalence rate refers to the proportion of a population that has experienced a condition at some point in their life. Such rates are used for personality disorders because they involve enduring patterns of behaviour.
- Footnote 16
-
CSC is part of the Federal, Provincial, Territorial Heads of Corrections Working Group on Health and Mental Health.
- Footnote 17
-
CSC partners with governmental and non-organizations across the country that provide supports to offenders with mental health needs, at both the national and provincial levels (e.g., Mental Health Commission of Canada, Canadian Mental Health Association, National Aboriginal Health Organization, etc.).
- Footnote 18
-
This involves collaboration with case management staff members (e.g., institutional/community POs) to assess the psychosocial needs of offenders with mental disorders, identify and develop linkage to community resources, and formulate comprehensive discharge plans to facilitate continuity of mental health services into the community.
- Footnote 19
-
Services include comprehensive assessment & intervention planning, direct service provision such as individual counselling, consulting with case management staff to assist in managing offenders in the community, and advocacy for offenders with mental health needs.
- Footnote 20
-
Conduct disorders in children and youth have been identified as a precursor of antisocial personality disorder in adults, which is a particularly prevalent disorder in the offender population. (Fazel, S., & Danesh, J. (2002). Serious mental disorder in 23000 prisoners: A systematic review of 62 surveys. The Lancet, 359(9306), 545-550).
- Footnote 21
-
MST is a program model that targets youth with serious behavioural issues by addressing the systems or settings related to the problematic behaviour. (MST Services, Inc. (2015). Multisystemic therapy. Retrieved from http://mstservices.com/what-is-mst/what-is-mst.).
- Footnote 22
-
For instance, among participants in Streets to Homes (a program in Toronto that offers help in finding long-term housing for homeless people), just under one half of sampled participants had mental disorders. Furthermore, the number of arrests and jail admittances were reduced by 56% and 68%, respectively (City of Toronto, 2009), as cited in Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, & Canadian Council on Social Development. (2011). Turning the key: Assessing housing and related supports for persons living with mental health problems and illness. Calgary, AB: Mental Health Commission of Canada.
- Footnote 23
-
Although this document refers to "assessments," note that assessment processes and tools also comprise a screening component.
- Footnote 24
-
Falls risk screening is also completed as part of the 24-hour intake assessment. If the screening criteria are met, offenders are referred for the Morse Falls Scale to determine whether fall prevention interventions should be implemented.
- Footnote 25
-
The Health Status Admission Assessment is also completed as part of the 14-day intake assessment for those who are 50 or older or those with self care needs, to identify any special health care needs for these populations. Note, as of August, 2015, the Health Status at Admission Assessment is completed for those who are 65 years or older or anyone with self-care needs.
- Footnote 26
-
The types of offender admission pertaining to each assessment are described on p.31 of this report.
- Footnote 27
-
Percentage of offenders interviewed during intake period who reported that they had completed each of the following intake health assessment tools: 24 hour and 14 day 95% (n=95), infectious disease screening 95% (n=93), and CoMHISS 89% (n=57).
- Footnote 28
-
CSC conducts Boards of Investigations (BOIs) when significant incidents occur as well as Mortality Reviews in the cases on deaths by natural causes. Only health-related BOIs were reviewed for this investigation including: assault of a staff member, assault of an inmate, suicide of an inmate, attempted suicide of an inmate, attempted suicide and subsequent death, self -inflicted injury of an inmate, overdoes interrupted, hostage-taking on an inmate, injury of inmate, death by unknown cause of an inmate.
- Footnote 29
-
The evaluation examined reports available at the time the evaluation commenced, which included reports that were convened and completed in fiscal year 2012-2013.
- Footnote 30
-
In most cases where a health intake assessment was completed late, it was the 14-day assessment, all of which were ultimately completed, and there was no evidence within the reports to suggest that the timing of the assessments had an impact on the incident. In one investigation, the Health Status Admission Assessment for offenders who are 50 or older was not completed; however, there was no evidence to suggest that its non-completion had an impact on the incident.
- Footnote 31
-
Less than one-quarter of health services respondents familiar with the tools identified any challenges to accuracy of the 24-hour (23%, n=13), 14-day (22%, n=11), or infectious disease assessment (14%, n=6). Few health services staff reported experiencing challenges referring offenders to health services based on the results of the 24-hour (24%, n=13), the 14-day (20%, n=10), or the infectious disease screening (10%, n=4). Note that number of respondents for each assessment tool varied, due to the fact that only staff members familiar with each of the assessment tools were asked to respond to these questions.
- Footnote 32
-
Based on interviews with a sample of offenders recently admitted to CSC (within 3 to 7 months of admission).
- Footnote 33
-
The following percentages of offenders interviewed at intake disagreed with the timing of intake assessments (14%, n=15). For staff questionnaire respondents, percentage disagreement was: 24-hour (13%, n=8), 14-day (20%, n=11), Infectious Disease Screening (20%, n=9), CoMHISS (32%, n= 7).
- Footnote 34
-
Note that the effectiveness and over-identification of needs could not be examined for all intake mental health assessment tools since information on referral from other intake tools is not tracked electronically.
- Footnote 35
-
CoMHISS identifies three groups of offenders: (1) Flagged: offenders require mental health follow-up; (2) Unclassified: offenders have a moderate need for mental health services and mental health staff are required to conduct at least a file review to determine whether or not an offender required follow-up mental health assessment or services; and, (3) Screened out: offenders do not require follow-up mental health services.
- Footnote 36
-
Among offenders who were unclassified, 39.5% (n=602, including 44 offenders admitted to a regional treatment centre) received mental health treatment and 60.5% (n=922) did not receive mental health treatment.
- Footnote 37
-
These percentages are comparable to those reported by Martin et al (2013) who examined the scoring model utilized in the current version of CoMHISS for all offenders admitted to the Pacific Region over a 15-month period from October 2006 to December 2007. See Martin, S., Wamboldt, A., O'Connor, S., Fortier, J., & Simpson, A. (2013). A comparison of scoring models for computerised mental health screening for federal prison inmates. Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health, 23(1), 6-17.
- Footnote 38
-
In order to examine the intake period, treatment-oriented services were only included if they were linked to a referral that was made within 4-months of the offender's admission. Treatment-oriented services included: group or individual counselling; group or individual mental health counselling; psychiatric clinic; skills training, self-care or activities of daily living; suicide or self-injury intervention; and, treatment planning.
- Footnote 39
-
Date of admission to a regional treatment centre was between the offender admission date in fiscal year 2013-14 or 2014-15 to the data extraction date in September, 2015.
- Footnote 40
-
This information was not available, since the sources of other referrals for mental health treatment (other than CoMHISS) are not tracked electronically.
- Footnote 41
-
1 offender refused the referral and 49 offenders refused at least one mental health service. The service may have been a treatment-oriented service or another service (such as an assessment that may have led to a future treatment-oriented service). Therefore all were included as refusals in this analysis.
- Footnote 42
-
Other issues may have impacted on these results, including the possibility that CoMHISS referrals or treatment were delayed beyond the initial intake period, or that data entry errors occurred in MHTS.
- Footnote 43
-
Communication and cultural challenges include language barriers and barriers with the assessment not identifying offenders' mental health issues due to cultural differences surrounding beliefs about mental health.
- Footnote 44
-
Percentages for staff ranged from 61% for 14-day intake assessment to 73% for COMHISS or infectious disease screening (see Appendix D for more information).
- Footnote 45
-
This represented the percentage of Indigenous offenders interested in following a traditional healing path who reported that they did not have an Elder present during health intake assessments.
- Footnote 46
-
The presence of Elders during health intake assessments is not specified in health services guidelines with the exception of CoMHISS where, according to the National Guidelines: Version 2.2 (June 2014), offenders may request the presence of an Indigenous advisor during the CoMHISS assessment.
- Footnote 47
-
These assessment tools are administered through different sources, formats and timeframes. For example the 24-hour assessment is administered early, it assesses offenders' immediate needs, and it is administered by a nurse. CoMHISS is administered after the 24-hour assessment, collects a broader scope of mental health information (including ADHD and cognitive deficiencies), and it is self-administered by the offender on a computer.
- Footnote 48
-
Note that many non-health services staff members reported that they did not know whether there was duplication or not. Percentages here are reported out of those staff members who were knowledgeable about the issue.
- Footnote 49
-
Few staff members (9%, n=4) identified challenges in the efficient administration of the infectious disease screening.
- Footnote 50
-
Referrals may also be submitted as a result of offender self-referral or staff observation.
- Footnote 51
-
For duplication of mental health care referrals: occasionally (21%), frequently (60%), always (4%).
- Footnote 52
-
Health services staff also reported that duplicate referrals came from health services intake assessment tools and staff referrals or offender self-referrals. Health services staff also noted that duplicate referrals are sometimes received from multiple different staff members (e.g., nurses, correctional officers).
- Footnote 53
-
Once an offender has completed an intake assessment and is determined to require a mental health referral, forms are completed and subsequently reviewed by the Chief Psychologist (or delegate) to determine the appropriate follow-up action. The evaluation team examined mental health services data for a two-year admission cohort (FY 2013-2014 and FY 2014-2015) of all federal offenders admitted with a warrant of committal to a federal institution. It is important to note that offenders admitted to a regional treatment centre are considered to have the highest level of mental health need and their mental health service information are not consistently entered into MHTS. Therefore, referrals within MHTS pertaining to offenders who were admitted to a regional treatment centre were excluded from analysis because the data would not be comprehensive for these offenders.
- Footnote 54
-
Of all offenders who had at least one referral (n=5643), 42% (n=2368) had only one referral and 58% (n=3275) had multiple referrals (32% received two referrals and 26% received three or more referrals).
- Footnote 55
-
These 68 offenders accounted for 75 of the referrals cancelled as duplicate referrals. Those referrals that are assigned to a mental health professional may subsequently result in further treatment, or the referrals could be cancelled by the mental health professional for reasons that could include cancellations due to duplicate referrals.
- Footnote 56
-
MHTS tracks by whom the referrals were made (e.g., mental health staff, health staff, parole officer, offender), but it does not identify the assessment tool from which the referral was made.
- Footnote 57
-
5% were referred based on all 3 tools; an additional 8% had referrals from both CoMHISS and the 24-hour assessment; 5% had referrals from both CoMHISS and the 14-day assessment; and, 3% had referrals from both the 24-hour and the 14-day assessments.
- Footnote 58
-
For duplication of physical health care referrals: occasionally (26%), frequently (46%), always (8%).
- Footnote 59
-
Information on physical health referrals is not currently tracked electronically. Therefore, it was not possible to assess the degree to which multiple referrals for physical health care may be made for offenders through any source of physical health data.
- Footnote 60
-
Note that a small percentage of staff also reported duplication between each of the four main health services assessment tools and other health related tools conducted at intake. However, respondents did not specifically identify which of the other health related tools included duplicate physical health information.
- Footnote 61
-
Non-essential clinical health services may consist of orthotics, respiratory devices, chiropractic services, and fluoride treatments. Such services are at the offender's expense; Health Services may assist in coordinating the offender's access to these services.
- Footnote 62
-
Clinical health related appointments within the last year: 90% (n=122) of offenders reported having had an appointment with a doctor, 61% (n=83) with a nurse and 32% (n=44) with a dentist.
- Footnote 63
-
"Offenders in CSC who are known to be infected with HIV are offered treatment for infection. Decisions on starting the treatment and remaining on treatment due to side effects, resistance or response are clinical decisions made by the treating infectious disease expert and the patient." (p.14)
- Footnote 64
-
Intermediate mental health services were not included in the scope of this evaluation due to the fact that intermediate mental health care was not fully implemented in CSC institutions at the commencement of the evaluation.
- Footnote 65
-
Flow-through population refers to the number of offenders that have been in an institution over a given time period.
- Footnote 66
-
Mental health services may include counselling, crisis intervention, and skills training.
- Footnote 67
-
Mental health related appointments within the last year: a few offenders reported having had an appointment with a psychiatrist (24%, n=33), psychologist (21%, n=29), or social worker (3%, n=4).
- Footnote 68
-
Percentage of flagged offenders who received a follow-up service by region in 2014: Atlantic 99% (n=207); Quebec 98% (n=212); Ontario 99% (n=270); Prairies 93% (n=286); and, Pacific 73% (n=53). Offenders are to receive a follow-up service within 50 days of admission or 40 days from referral.
- Footnote 69
-
Note that there may be some differences in reporting practices across provinces.
- Footnote 70
-
The statuses of the other 6 calls were: 1 individual was admitted to the Regional Hospital, 2 individuals refused care and 3 were disposition unknown.
- Footnote 71
-
Under the U.S. Department of Justice, the U.S. correctional systems included in the review were federal prisons in: Colorado, Pennsylvania, Louisiana, Wyoming, and Texas.
- Footnote 72
-
Of those, n=19 reported receiving ongoing health care for clinical heath, n=10 for mental health, and n=4 for infectious disease at the time of their transfer.
- Footnote 73
-
For all five CSC regions included in the CORR monitoring, non-compliance was found in the Atlantic, Quebec, Prairie and Pacific regions.
- Footnote 74
-
Two groups of health services staff were surveyed for the evaluation: those working with offenders at intake and those working with offenders during incarceration (after penitentiary placement). The information reported in this section was collected from health services staff working with offenders during the incarceration period. However, some general questions related to access to care and information sharing were also asked of health services staff working at intake. Responses of intake staff were scanned for commonality or differences of themes and issues. Overall, the pattern of responses for staff working with offenders at intake was similar to those working with offenders during the incarceration period.
- Footnote 75
-
For example, a correctional officer may not "need-to-know" the specific medications an offender is taking; however, they may need to know symptoms related to the medication relating to mobility or behaviours that could affect security or case management.
- Footnote 76
-
Note that these included all BOIs for investigated incidents at the Tier I and II levels in 2013-14 and 2014-15 that had been investigated and completed. Not all 2013-14 and 2014-15 BOI cases had been completed at the time the data was obtained.
- Footnote 77
-
Implementation in all institutions in Ontario and Pacific, and one institution in remaining regions, is scheduled to begin in September 2016, with full implementation to all institutions scheduled for March 2017.
- Footnote 78
-
For women, PEC and the Peer Support Program for Women have recently been integrated into a new program called the Peer Mentorship program which is anticipated to be implemented in 2016-2017.
- Footnote 79
-
Health information and materials are presented both during the intake period (most commonly RAP, ISAPW) and throughout incarceration after penitentiary placement (most commonly PEC/APEC, fact sheets). Two sets of interviews were conducted with two different groups of offenders: at intake and during incarceration (after pen placement). Results in these sections are presented from either of these samples when and where applicable.
- Footnote 80
-
The expected locations of PEC did not include maximum security, RTC/RPCs, receptions centres and the healing lodge.
- Footnote 81
-
Not all expected institutions had an active PEC program across the regions, with 4/5 in Atlantic, 7/9 in Quebec, 10/11 in Ontario, 7/9 in Prairie and 7/7 in Pacific.
- Footnote 82
-
The expected locations of APEC were more in areas with a high population of Indigenous offenders such as Prairie region and in healing lodges.
- Footnote 83
-
Not all expected institutions had an active APEC program across the regions, with 2/2 in Atlantic, 2/4 in Quebec, 4/4 in Ontario, 10/11 in Prairie and 5/5 in Pacific.
- Footnote 84
-
Of the offenders who were interviewed, 14% (n=21) participated in PEC and 7% (n=11) participated in APEC to become PEC or APEC support workers, respectively. A few (n=8) offenders reported that they were currently a PEC/APEC support worker/volunteer.
- Footnote 85
-
Additionally, the narrated version of RAP can be run via monitors in the Health Services waiting room.
- Footnote 86
-
Most offenders also reported that materials delivered through RAP (97%, n=37), PEC/APEC (95%, n=18), and ISAPW (92%, n=35) were easy to understand.
- Footnote 87
-
HIV: Men and women offenders who attended health education programs were more knowledgeable about HIV (83%; 86%) than men and women offenders who did not attend education programs (78%; 80%).
- Footnote 88
-
HCV: Similarly, men and women offenders who attended health education programs were also more knowledgeable about HCV (73%; 78%) compared to men and women offenders who did not attend education programs (68%; 68%).
- Footnote 89
-
Many general staff also agreed that education programs/materials in general had a positive impact on offenders' awareness of health services and programs in CSC and how to access them (67%, n=30).
- Footnote 90
-
Direct and indirect costs represent medical costs, labor productivity costs, and loss of quality of life.
- Footnote 91
-
Other federal government organizations include; the Public Health Agency of Canada, the Canadian Institute of Health Research, and Health Canada.
- Footnote 92
-
CSC surveillance data indicate the majority of offenders with HIV/HCV infection acquired infection prior to federal incarceration.
- Footnote 93
-
A more detailed list of these programs and services includes: staff education and training, screening and testing, HIV testing normalization, addictions screening, health education and awareness, anti HIV-stigma campaigns, peer support programs, risk assessment and counselling, vaccination, diagnosis and treatment of viral hepatitis (A&B), substance abuse counselling, opiate substitution therapy, overdose emergency response and counselling, bleach distribution, mental health referral/counselling, condom/dental dam distribution, post-exposure prophylaxis, HIV and HCV treatment, discharge planning, prevention, diagnosis and treatment of TB.
- Footnote 94
-
These results are from a pre two year and post two years time period.
- Footnote 95
-
In the two years following MMTP initiation, the proportion of successful program completions or attendance more than doubled for substance abuse programs, increasing from approximately 29% in the pre period to 63% in the post period.
- Footnote 96
-
The risk of re-incarceration was 36% higher for male non-MMPT offenders compared to MMPT offenders who continued methadone treatments.
- Footnote 97
-
Health services staff and general staff reported that condoms (99%, n=99; 91%, n=73), bleach kits (83%, n=83; 86%, n=69), dental dams (70%, n=70; 56%, n=45), and lubricants (74%, n=74; 63%, n=50) are available in their institutions, respectively.
- Footnote 98
-
Intermediate mental health services were not included in the scope of this evaluation because these services were not fully implemented in CSC institutions at the start of the evaluation.
- Footnote 99
-
Some offenders received treatment at both mainstream institutions and RTCs. These offenders were included in the "RTC group" for analysis. The focus was on the impacts of care received while at a RTC (i.e., "after treatment" outcomes were assessed following RTC treatment, whether or not other treatment may have continued following return to the institution).
- Footnote 100
-
Institutional charges may differ from institutional incidents, as correctional staff members may resolve an institutional incident informally (CD 580; CCRA section 41 (1) & (2)). Institutional incidents were included for analysis if the offender was identified as an instigator or an associate in the incident.
- Footnote 101
-
Statistical analysis of voluntary segregation could not be conducted due to low rates of the indicator.
- Footnote 102
-
In addition to assault, behaviour, and self-harm, other incident sub-categories are recorded in OMS (i.e., possession of contraband, property offences, escapes, and deaths). Although all sub-categories were included in the analysis for "overall incidents," only the three categories with theoretical links to mental health needs were included for sub-incident analysis (i.e., assault, behavior, self-harm).
- Footnote 103
-
Treatment-oriented services included: mental health counselling: group/individual; psychiatric clinic; skills training/self-care/activities of daily living (ADL); suicide or self-injury intervention; treatment planning; counselling: group/individual. Many offenders had more than one "treatment period," but the treatment period with the most treatment services was selected to be included in the analysis.
- Footnote 104
-
Separate statistical analyses were not conducted for women offenders due to the smaller number of women offenders receiving mainstream institutional mental health treatment. However, they are included in the overall sample of "all offenders".
- Footnote 105
-
Separate statistical analyses were not conducted for Indigenous and women offenders due to the smaller number of Indigenous and women offenders receiving treatment at a RTC. However, they are included in the overall sample of "all offenders".
- Footnote 106
-
Behaviour related incidents include: minor/major disturbances, disruptive behaviour, substance use, disciplinary problems, threats towards staff/others and cell extraction.
- Footnote 107
-
Offenders in the comparison group were 16.6% (HR = 0.834; 95% CI = 0.770-0.903) less likely to be involuntarily segregated closer to the end of their sentence, compared to the beginning of their sentence.
- Footnote 108
-
Offenders in the comparison group were 15% (HR = 1.150; 95% CI = 1.028-1.288) more likely to complete an education course or credit closer to the end of their sentence, compared to the beginning of their sentence.
- Footnote 109
-
Offenders in the comparison group were 21.8% (HR = 1.218; 95% CI = 1.148 – 1.293) more likely to complete a national correctional program in the middle of their sentence compared to the beginning of their sentence.
- Footnote 110
-
Referrals are reviewed and offenders may not be admitted to a RTC due to their eligibility or lack of consent.
- Footnote 111
-
This information was extracted from MHTS for this evaluation.
- Footnote 112
-
Offenders receiving treatment in RTCs in two regions were interviewed (N=32) about their experiences with receiving care. Due to the varied health conditions of this population and the small number of offenders interviewed, the questions were asked in a more open-ended fashion designed to elicit discussion around specific themes related to admission, treatment and services received.
- Footnote 113
-
Some of the remaining RTC offenders did not report awareness or involvement in treatment planning (21%, n=6). Others reported awareness of the planning process (e.g., having meetings), but did not recall being involved in developing their treatment plan and objectives (32%, n=9).
- Footnote 114
-
Implementation of intermediate mental health care was completed in April 2016.
- Footnote 115
-
If offenders are assessed as no need or low need on the MHNS, self-care may also be an option if necessary, for example psycho-educational sessions on a particular mental health topic or skill development.
- Footnote 116
-
Health Services Sector reported that electronic data on MHNS was not always being entered as required.
- Footnote 117
-
Use caution when interpreting the results from general staff members due to the small number of respondents.
- Footnote 118
-
The Audit of Release Process (2012) also found offenders were not always released with their medications.
- Footnote 119
-
Extracted from the data warehouse on 2016-02-28 for all offenders active on that date. Offenders were coded as having a health card if their most recent record from OMS indicated they had a health card in their possession, in their personal effects, of with a community support person.
- Footnote 120
-
The Audit sampled release files from the period of April 2010 through March 2011.
- Footnote 121
-
Based on consultation with Regional Directors of Health Services (RDHSs) in August, 2016.
- Footnote 122
-
Based on consultation with RDHSs in August, 2016.
- Footnote 123
-
The Health Status at Discharge: Gist Report includes other health related information related to release, such as any appointments required with community health care specialists and any accommodation needs related to functional and/or cognitive impairment, etc.
- Footnote 124
-
Included: Clinical Discharge Planners, Community Mental Health Nurses, Clinical Social Workers
- Footnote 125
-
Note that not all staff responded to this question. Percentages are reported out of the total number of staff responses to this question.
- Footnote 126
-
Included: Clinical Discharge Planners, Community Mental Health Nurses, Clinical Social Workers.
- Footnote 127
-
Community-based ID clinics are offered in multiple regions, for example, through community housing resource centres, community health centres, legal clinics, and other community service organisations.
- Footnote 128
-
This is in addition to community health expenditures in other areas such as mental health and other general administrative, nursing or methadone costs.
- Footnote 129
-
Source: Integrated Financial and Material Management System (IFMMS), extracted September, 2016.
- Footnote 130
-
The type of medication dictates the duration of the supply provided at discharge. According to the CSC National Formulary, non-narcotic and non-controlled mediations are generally provided for 14 days; whereas, narcotic and controlled medications (e.g., ADHD medications) are provided for 3-days and at the discretion of the physician. This distinction is not clarified in the Discharge Planning and Transfer Guidelines or CD 712-4 Release Process.
- Footnote 131
-
This should be interpreted with caution because the risk profiles were not equivalent between groups and the group size for women offenders was too small to allow for survival analysis and only a fixed follow-up analysis was undertaken.
- Footnote 132
-
Community mental health services provided to offenders may include mental health counselling (individual or group), accompaniment support, suicide or self-injury intervention, assessments, etc.
- Footnote 133
-
CDP Timeframe: "The timing of referrals for CDP is guided by the offender's anticipated release date, the case management process and the anticipated level of need."
- Footnote 134
-
Remaining staff members either reported "neither agree nor disagree" (21%, n=30) or "disagree/strongly disagree" (36%, n=52).
- Footnote 135
-
Our sample included offenders on their first conditional release of FY2014-15, but only if they remained in the community for 30 days or more (this was done to allow time to receive mental health services).
- Footnote 136
-
Mental health need is defined as any offender who received a treatment-oriented mental health service 6 months prior to their release. Note that this provides an approximation of need. Reliable information from other data (such as the Mental Health Need Scale) was not available. Therefore, the receipt of a treatment-oriented mental health service in the institution 6 months prior to release was used as a proxy indicator of offender mental health need.
- Footnote 137
-
Absence of mental health need was identified as offenders who did not receive a treatment oriented service 6 months prior to release.
- Footnote 138
-
The Discharge Planning Matrix Tool was developed in April 2013 as a reference accompanying the Discharge Planning and Transfer Guidelines.
- Footnote 139
-
Numbers/percentages reflect the number of staff who reported that each of the following categories of staff "frequently" or "always" followed-up on clinical discharge plans.
- Footnote 140
-
65% (n=50) of staff who responded to this question indicated that at least 20% of offenders were released to area with limited community mental health specialists.
- Footnote 141
-
Figure 2 shows percentage of staff who agreed that the governance structure impacted specific issues. Remaining staff either disagreed that there had been an impact of the governance structure, or provided a neutral response "neither agree nor disagree".
- Footnote 142
-
This included both health services and general staff in the institution and the community.
- Footnote 143
-
Some (31%, n=40) health services staff disagreed or strongly disagreed that the health services for offenders with multiple health care needs are delivered in an integrated manner to best address their needs. A few (16%, n=20) neither agreed nor disagreed that the health services for offenders with multiple health care needs are delivered in an integrated manner.
- Footnote 144
-
The Mental Health Branch also reports its information disaggregated by sex and Indigenous or non-Indigenous status.
- Footnote 145
-
Public health planning: 26% (n=23) agreed; 38% (n=33) neither agreed nor disagreed; and 36% (n=31) disagreed. Clinical health planning: 33% (n=32) agreed; 34% (n=33) neither agreed nor disagreed; and 32% (n=31) disagreed.
Mental health planning: 34% (n=37) agreed; 36% (n=39) neither agreed nor disagreed; and 31% (n=34) disagreed.
- Footnote 146
-
Direct program spending includes strategic outcome spending (custody, correctional interventions and community supervision), but excludes spending on internal services.
- Footnote 147
-
Research has shown the rate of late relapse occurs in less than 1% of patients.
- Footnote 148
-
The prevalence rates reported in this section were based on offender self-report upon admission and do not take into account test results completed as part of the intake period. Self-reported rates of infectious diseases may be lower than actual prevalence rates. Some information on prevalence rates for specific groups of offenders in CSC from 2000-2006 is available at http://www.csc-scc.gc.ca/publications/infdscfp-2005-06/tb-eng.shtml.
- Footnote 149
-
Due to self-reported frequencies of less than five, the prevalence rates for HCV and HIV were reported together in the source research report.
- Footnote 150
-
These figures are for one-month current prevalence rates.
- Footnote 151
-
Use caution when interpreting these results given the small number of offenders in the Indigenous group in some categories.
- Footnote 152
-
Where possible current rates are provided; however, in some cases, only lifetime rates were available.
- Footnote 153
-
Percentage of Health Services Staff Questionnaire participants reporting no barriers/challenges for Indigenous offenders: 24-hour (82%, n=44), 14-day (80%, n=41), infectious disease screening (86%, n=36) and CoMHISS (72%, n=13). No Indigenous offenders interviewed at intake reported any specific barriers to intake assessments (0%, n = 31).
- Footnote 154
-
Percentage of Health Services Staff Questionnaire participants reporting that Elders were never or rarely involved in completing intake assessment tools: 24-hour Assessment (64%, n=38), 14-day Health Intake Assessment (61%, n=34), Infectious Disease Screening (73%, n=33); or CoMHISS (73%, n=16).
- Footnote 155
-
Of those offenders who participated in the current evaluation, 33% (n=34) identified themselves as being Indigenous of First Nations (84%; n=27) or Métis (16%; n=5) descent, and of those 68% (n=23) expressed an interest in following a traditional healing path.
- Footnote 156
-
24-hour assessment - 97% (n=4192) of the whole offender population (Indigenous and non-Indigenous) were screened within the appropriate timeframe compared to 94% (904) of Indigenous offenders. 14-day assessment – 70% (n=3010) of the whole offender population (Indigenous and non-Indigenous) were screened within the appropriate timeframes compared to 70% (n=659) of Indigenous offenders.
- Footnote 157
-
Percentage of Health Services Staff Questionnaire participants reporting no barriers/challenges for visible minority offenders: 24-hour (83%, n=45), 14-day (77%, n=39), infectious disease screening (85%, n=34) and CoMHISS (67%, n=12).
- Footnote 158
-
Percentage of Health Services Staff Questionnaire participants reporting no barriers/challenges for older offenders: 24-hour (80%, n=44), 14-day (86%, n=44), infectious disease screening (88%, n=35) and CoMHISS (75%, n=12). Almost all older offenders who responded to this interview question reported that they did not experience any specific barriers in completing intake assessments (93%, n=13).
- Footnote 159
-
It is difficult to draw conclusions from this information, given the small number of offenders who identified as an older offender (i.e., over the age of fifty) who participated in the evaluation interviews during the intake assessment period (n=16). Older offender health requirements and services will be assessed in additional aspects of the evaluation where possible.
- Footnote 160
-
Percentage of Health Services Staff Questionnaire participants reporting no barriers/challenges for women offenders: 24-hour (88%, n=28), 14-day (88%, n=30), infectious disease screening (90%, n=26) and CoMHISS (100%, n=11). Almost all women offenders interviewed at intake reported that they did not experience any specific barriers in completing intake assessments (95%, n=19). Of those offenders who participated in the current evaluation, 20% (n=21) were women.
- Footnote 161
-
24-hour assessment - 97% (n=4192) of the whole offender population (women and men) were screened within the appropriate timeframe compared to 98% (232) of women offenders. 14-day assessment – 70% (n=3010) of the whole offender population (women and men) were screened within the appropriate timeframes compared to 87% (n=204) of women offenders. CoMHISS – 84% (n=3538) of whole offender population (women and men) were screened within the appropriate timeframes compared to 80% (n=189) of women offenders.
- Footnote 162
-
Health services staff members reported that RAP included information on the health services available at CSC (87%, n=33), how to access these services (92%, n=35), how to prevent infectious disease in prison (95%, n=36).
- Footnote 163
-
The Discharge Planning Matrix Tool was developed in April 2013 as a reference accompanying the Discharge Planning and Transfer Guidelines.
- Footnote 164
-
The total offender population includes all active offenders, who were incarcerated in a CSC facility, offenders who were on temporary absence from a CSC facility, offenders who were temporarily detained, offenders who were actively supervised, and offenders who were unlawfully at large for less than 90 days.
- Footnote 165
-
Results for physical health were based on a file review of offender self-reported health needs at intake, and results for mental health were obtained from clinical tools used with a sample of offenders.
- Footnote 166
-
Remaining staff either reported "neither agree nor disagree" or "disagree/strongly disagree".
- Footnote 167
-
The total offender population includes all active offenders, who were incarcerated in a CSC facility, offenders who were on temporary absence from a CSC facility, offenders who were temporarily detained, offenders who were actively supervised, and offenders who were unlawfully at large for less than 90 days.
- Footnote 168
-
Results for physical health were based on a file review of offender self-reported health needs at intake, and results for mental health were obtained from structured clinical interviews used with a sample of offenders.
- Footnote 169
-
Culturally-safe services are provided by professionals that are aware and understand Indigenous culture and are open and supportive an offender's choice regarding traditional Indigenous healing practices.
- Footnote 170
-
Collaboration within and outside of CSC refers internally to collaboration between CSC NHQ, RHQs and each institution; between the Health Services Sector and Aboriginal Initiatives Directorate. Externally, collaboration should occur between internal partners and with the Indigenous Community, and at the federal and provincial/territorial level.
- Footnote 171
-
Remaining staff either reported "neither agree nor disagree" or "disagree/strongly disagree".
- Footnote 172
-
The total offender population includes all active offenders, who were incarcerated in a CSC facility, offenders who were on temporary absence from a CSC facility, offenders who were temporarily detained, offenders who were actively supervised, and offenders who were unlawfully at large for less than 90 days.
- Footnote 173
-
Remaining staff either reported "neither agree nor disagree" or "disagree/strongly disagree".
- Footnote 174
-
The total offender population includes all active offenders, who were incarcerated in a CSC facility, offenders who were on temporary absence from a CSC facility, offenders who were temporarily detained, offenders who were actively supervised, and offenders who were unlawfully at large for less than 90 days.
- Footnote 175
-
Results for physical health were based on a file review of offender self-reported health needs at intake.
- Footnote 176
-
CSC operated healing lodges.
- Footnote 177
-
As of August 2015, the age requirement to conduct.
- Footnote 178
-
Screening for "falls risk" is a Required Organizational Practice under Accreditation Canada.
- Footnote 179
-
Remaining staff either reported "neither agree nor disagree" or "disagree/strongly disagree".
Page details
- Date modified: