Annex E: Court Martial Appeal Court of Canada Statistics

CMAC # Appellant Respondent Type of Appeal Result
553 Her Majesty the Queen Mr. Paul Wehmeier Legality of Finding Dismissed.
558 Pte Larouche Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Appeal granted. Acquitted.
559 Lt Watts Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding/Severity of Sentence New trial ordered on charge 4 (unlawfully causing bodily harm) and charge 5 (negligent performance of a military duty). Finding of not guilty recorded for charge 6 (negligent performance of duty). DMP decided not to pursue this matter further.
561 Sgt Arsenault Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Dismissed
565 MCpl Laflamme Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding New trial ordered.
566 Pte Déry Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Held in abeyance pending the SCC decision in Moriarity et al. v R.
567 MCpl Stillman Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Held in abeyance pending the SCC decision in Moriarity et al. v R.
568 MCpl Royes Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Appeal dismissed on all grounds except for the constitutional question. A hearing date in regard to the question will be scheduled once the SCC has rendered its decision in Moriarity et al. v R.
569 Her Majesty the Queen MCpl Holloway Legality of Finding Abandoned.
571 Maj Wellwood Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Held in abeyance pending the SCC decision in Moriarity et al. v R.
572 Her Majesty the Queen WO Brideau Legality of Finding Abandoned.
573 Capt Yurczyszyn Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Abandoned.
574 PO2 Wilks Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Held in abeyance pending the SCC decision in Moriarity et al. v R.
575 OS Cawthorne Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Appeal heard on 20 Feb 15, decision under reserve.
576 Cpl Laliberté Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Abandoned.
577 Her Majesty the Queen WO Gagnon Legality of Finding Ongoing.
578 Lt(N) Klein Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Held in abeyance pending the SCC decision in Moriarity et al. v R.
579 Cpl Nadeau-Dion Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Held in abeyance pending the SCC decision in Moriarity et al. v R.
580 Cpl Pfahl Her Majesty the Queen Legality of Finding Held in abeyance pending the SCC decision in Moriarity et al. v R.
581 Her Majesty the Queen Cpl Thibault Legality of Finding Ongoing.

Footnotes

1 Sgt Arsenault.

2 PO2 Wilks.

Page details

Date modified: