# 2024-139 Careers, RMC Physical Performance Test

Case summary

F&R Date: 2025-12-11

The grievor challenged the Canadian Armed Forces' (CAF) decision to change his academic path to a 30-credit General Science degree from his previous 40-credit Engineering degree. As redress, the grievor requested a transfer to the Continuing Education Officer Training Plan at the Royal Military College of Canada (RMC) or a similar training program that would allow him to complete the 40-credit Engineering degree. 

The Commandant Canadian Defence Academy, acting as the Initial Authority (IA), denied the grievance asserting that the grievor had been given several months to concentrate on his physical training with limited other activities assigned; however, was ultimately unsuccessful in the RMC Physical Performance Test (PPT). The IA determined that the decision to allow him to obtain a 30-credit degree, which according to the Entry Standards for members enrolled under Regular Officer Training Program was acceptable to his occupation, was appropriate. The IA found that the grievor had been treated fairly and in accordance with applicable rules, regulations, and policies.

The Committee determined that the grievor was granted several months to focus on physical training, with limited additional responsibilities, and was provided multiple attempts to pass the RMC PPT. Despite these opportunities, he was unsuccessful and did not meet all requirements to graduate from RMC. Nevertheless, he was afforded the chance to complete a 30-credit program and continue his military career in his chosen occupation. Additionally, he was offered the opportunity for early commissioning. The Committee found that, in the grievor's circumstances considering the potential alternatives, including release, the CAF's decision was fair, justified, and consistent with policy and therefore, the grievor was not aggrieved by this decision. The Committee also noted that given the unique circumstances of the specialized Engineering Degree sought, the grievor's advancement in that degree, he was ultimately allowed to complete the 40-credit degree at RMC. The Committee recommended that the Final Authority not afford the grievor redress.